4 ms·
Posting fake reviews on Amazon is a prisoner’s dilemma at this point. I’m not surprised to see even top brands getting caught up in it, because if you don’t do
by paxys 6y ago
Posting fake reviews on Amazon is a prisoner’s dilemma at this point. I’m not surprised to see even top brands getting caught up in it, because if you don’t do it your competitors most certainly will.
- fmajid 5y agoIt's more devious than that. You have companies posting obviously fake 5-star reviews of competitors' products to get them banned for review manipulation. I doubt that was the case with Aukey. https://www.theverge.com/2018/12/19/18140799/amazon-marketplace-scams-seller-court-appeal-reinstatement https://www.theverge.com/2018/12/19/18140799/amazon-marketpl...
- totalZero 5y agoIt almost makes you wonder if we should have a review system that doesn't include stars at all.
- fmajid 5y agoIt doesn't matter, any crowdsourced review system can and will be gamed, just as any communications service can and will be spammed. What is unsaid is that it's not just unscrupulous companies (including Amazon) that are involved. There are also ordinary consumers who deliberately post the fake 5-star reviews in exchange for compensation. I've seen people make excuses for them, but I can't see how any of them can be under the impression they are not doing wrong. Now if Amazon were forced to disclose statistics about return rates or complaints on products, that would in fact be valuable information. It could still be gamed due to other shoddy Amazon practices like allowing a merchant to start a listing for a cheap but genuinely good product, collect good reviews, then switch the product description to something completely unrelated.
- totalZero 5y agoThe gaming will be different though. It's easy to adulterate a numerical average of a low-effort star rating, and harder to fake a review written in English with pictures and details.
- pessimizer 5y ago> harder to fake a review written in English with pictures and details. It's also a lot harder to get a legitimate review like that. Instead of 100 reviews where 80 were fake, there will be 3 reviews where 2 are fake and the other was disputed by the seller (or paid off by the seller) and deleted.
- totalZero 5y agoAmazon is under no obligation to delete negative reviews that are "disputed," and I for one have written reviews of horrible products that I would never change nor delete, even for money. There is a weird defeatist mentality in this thread of "why try anything because sellers are just going to game it," but that's the wrong way to think when you're designing a human system. It's like writing a Constitution, insofar as you have to predict and hedge against the gamesmanship beforehand. If the review mills are in China or other non-Anglophone places, then removing stars and forcing them to be substantive makes it much harder because they would literally have to actually review the product. A reader can't differentiate between five fake stars and five real stars, but would probably be able to differentiate between an empty positive review and a well-presented negative review.
- ukoki 5y agoI guess they'll never go for this but they could do something like select 1% of buyers at random and pay them (or refund product cost) to write a meaningful review with pictures with updates at fixed intervals so the product is evaluated throughout its intended lifespan. Perhaps with some pre-filtering to improve the likelihood that reviews will be useful and accurate (eg "spent more than $10k on amazon", "billing address is shipping address", "previous reviews were voted as useful" etc)
- alok-g 5y agohttps://www.amazon.com/gp/vine/help https://www.amazon.com/gp/vine/help
- collaborative 5y agoAt least for app reviews; the rating should only be (opt-in) metrics with avg session time, crash %, etc. Fake reviews are beyond repair at this point
- TheRealDunkirk 5y agoIt almost makes you wonder if we shouldn't just go back to brick-and-mortar stores, where the "rating system" is implied by the "curation" of the store itself. Physical shelf space being limited, they're only going to carry the stuff that sells well (on the longer timeline of word-of-mouth through actual conversations), and that doesn't get returned very often.
- totalZero 5y agoThat is not unique to brick and mortar. Amazon could stop commingling its inventory with third part inventory, and Amazon has the ability to curate the products it sells. But Amazon chooses not to do that. Similarly, when I buy a product from Walmart for delivery to my house, it's curated despite brick and mortar being zero percent of the equation.
- TheRealDunkirk 5y agoYou say it's not unique, but this is exactly what used to make Amazon great, and they stopped. They couldn't help themselves from carrying everything under the sun from anyone willing to give them a couple of bucks, and they will never go back. Even NewEgg, which has traditionally been the counterpoint to Amazon, is now doing much the same thing. So, to be pedantic, it IS unique to brick and mortar, at this point. That's the point.
- libertine 5y agoNo, it's the other way around: these guys, and many others, were pioneers in these fields of breaking Amazon TOS without any consequences. They knew they could get away with it, became part of their modus operandi, like a playbook for every new product launched. But don't take me wrong: I blame all of this on Amazon, they nurtured this for years, by trimming away honest sellers and giving wealth to shady ones. My example: few weeks after I launched my product in an under developed market on Amazon, a new guy came in. For every ~80 sales I'd get one review, while the guy was getting 7-10 reviews for the same amount of sales (mostly 5 stars). How can you compete with a review velocity that's no where close the organic one?
- acdha 5y agoI also like the way they choose not to offer an easy way to report fake reviews. If you get offers to review someone’s products, Amazon will reliably and quickly delete a review saying that the company solicits fake/paid reviews but if you try to report it any other way you’ll never hear back or see any signs of a change in behavior.
- varispeed 5y agoYou also have companies creating fake Amazon accounts using stolen personal data, then purchasing their products and leaving verified reviews. I have many times received products I didn't order from Amazon and they don't seem to be doing anything about this.