3 ms·
Psychology has been using "bio-monitoring" since Helmholtz, although they think of it as involuntary or unconscious (modification of) response, e.g. reaction ti
by tgv 5y ago
Psychology has been using "bio-monitoring" since Helmholtz, although they think of it as involuntary or unconscious (modification of) response, e.g. reaction time, pupil dilation, heart rate. It all has the same problem: the distance between the hypothesis, the experimental manipulation, and the measurement is large and badly understood. Differences between conditions are then ascribed to noise, which enables "creative" interpretations of the results.
As an example: in the field in which I worked, it was commonly assumed that the processing mechanism had to interpret a part of the stimulus as belonging to one thing or the other. Then they would manipulate the context to see how they could influence that. There were many results and experimental refinements, leading to an endless stream of contradictory articles, all claiming victory for their theory. But there are models in which this assumption doesn't make sense. Instead, it could belong to both, and the ambiguity would be resolved later. That makes the whole research line I described nonsense. The data is valid (if well documented), but the analyses and conclusions are not.
A genetics statistician explained to me that all early genetic research (and that means up until 2000 at least) is highly unreliable, because they used Neyman-Fisher significance testing with high p values, like 0.01. The lack of understanding was (and probably still is) so great, that 0.01 was simply not enough to exclude random results. Nearly all those papers are irreproducible. Nowadays, 5 sigma, which is less than 0.000001, is considered safe, although he himself was convinced that Bayesian is the only way to go.
The understanding of the subject in psychology is considerably worse than in biology. No amount of bio-monitoring is going to overcome that.
- dmingod666 5y agoI know, it would have been fine if it was just another discipline of science or research that was hard to study.. The amount of interest from regular people and in the subject and the demand for research is so much that people want to hang on to twigs.. most people want to improve themselves and be able to think and do better and take atleast a fleeting interest in psychology... Evidenced by the rise of Jordon Peterson - I recently found Dr.Andrew Huberman to be a voice of reason (check out his Youtube podcast, its very information-dense and pretty good) - He approaches things from a neurobiology perspective. To navigate around getting a deeper understanding yourself, I thing a chemical / hormone / neurotransmitter based discussion at least grounds your feet in real things, from which you can probably explore things for yourself.. It also eliminates a lot of the cruft from the discussion..