2 ms·
> Do you honestly believe you've got a better handle on the legalities of this than the person whose job this is? The legalities are pretty clear; the judge i
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> Do you honestly believe you've got a better handle on the legalities of this than the person whose job this is?
The legalities are pretty clear; the judge is able to dismiss the case. I don't believe I know that more than the judge does; he also knew that he was legally able to dismiss the case.
Whether he exercises that power is a political question, not a legal question. But to this point:
> They may do so - may meaning they are allowed to - if it is obvious that there was no crime or there is insufficient evidence or there was a procedural error etc. (rules for this can vary greatly).
None of those is necessary. In the case I witnessed, the reasoning was quite obviously "the defendant is too young for this to make any sense", and the official statement was "the case is dismissed in the interest of justice".
- chmod775 6y ago> "the case is dismissed in the interest of justice" In the US that is possible in only about 12-15 jurisdictions, depending on who's counting. Some explicitly spell out in which cases a judge may do so, others leave that power broadly undefined. I wonder why, having seen that done once, you seem so insistent to extrapolate that judges everywhere and always must have that power.