4 ms·
It’s not just “conservatives.” It’s something National Review and Jacobin can agree on: https://jacobinmag.com/2020/06/brands-corporate-publicity-racial-justice
by rayiner 6y ago
It’s not just “conservatives.” It’s something National Review and Jacobin can agree on: https://jacobinmag.com/2020/06/brands-corporate-publicity-racial-justice https://jacobinmag.com/2020/06/brands-corporate-publicity-ra.... Solidly left-wing Democrats like Tulsi Gabbard have spoken out against it, and left-wing journalists like Matt Taibbi, Glenn Greeneald, etc.
The right wing opposes it because it attacks American history and readily dispenses with notions of race neutral application of the law. The left wing opposes it because it’s transparent whitewashing and also divides the working class against itself.
- geofft 6y ago> Solidly left-wing Democrats like Tulsi Gabbard ???
- rayiner 6y agoGabbard is to the left of Biden—she supports single payer healthcare, etc. She has a few heterodox takes, such as supporting the Hyde amendment and certain other restrictions. But almost half of Democrat voters support the Hyde, and the majority oppose late term abortions. The fact that anyone would think Gabbard isn’t solidly left wing is a sign of how distorted the media bubble is.
- tptacek 6y agoGabbard is not to Biden's left, and what you're noting is the intrinsic incoherency of the "left-right" divide. Gabbard is an economic populist who makes calculated appeals to the white working class. She's a purer incarnation of what Trump represented in 2016, and nobody felt Trump was to the left of even Hillary Clinton. The brain poisoning here is that Gabbard has been instrumentalized by marginal "right-wing" activists as a cudgel to use against Democrats (I'm not making value judgements, Democrats have their own box of cudgels). What gives away the game is that you only hear spirited defenses of Gabbard from right-libertarians. Gabbard is herself a marginal political figure and the fact that we discuss her at all is itself an indication that something is wrong. I'm relating this because it's interesting, not because I have a powerful stake in how this discussion plays out here. We're not going to solve American politics in an HN thread. I'm just saying: it's way more complicated than you let on, and, while the media bubble is certainly very distorted, this isn't a good sign of it.
- rayiner 6y ago> noting is the intrinsic incoherency of the "left-right" divide. Gabbard is an economic populist who makes calculated appeals to the white working class. She's a purer incarnation of what Trump represented in 2016, and nobody felt Trump was to the left of even Hillary Clinton. Trump didn’t support universal healthcare, have an F rating from the NRA, etc. > What gives away the game is that you only hear spirited defenses of Gabbard from right-libertarians. Gabbard is herself a marginal political figure and the fact that we discuss her at all is itself an indication that something is wrong. I don’t know anything about “right libertarians.” I was curious about Gabbard because she was the only one besides Klobuchar who sounded like she wasn’t reading from some memo everyone got. I also have no idea why the Democratic Party functionaries hate her so much. The occasional heterodox take she has, “we shouldn’t be racist against white people” or “maybe safe, legal, and rare was a good position,” are not controversial.
- tptacek 6y agoTulsi Gabbard ran in 2019 in part on rapprochement with the NRA, so that's not a great example. Trump ran against Cruz in 2016 on universal health care, and was attacked relentlessly by the GOP field for it. See what I mean? I think Gabbard is horrible but I'm not interested in selling you on that. Rather, I'd just like to point out that she's a complicated figure, and not a good left-right benchmark.
- rayiner 5y ago> Tulsi Gabbard ran in 2019 in part on rapprochement with the NRA, so that's not a great example. Trump ran against Cruz in 2016 on universal health care, and was attacked relentlessly by the GOP field for it. See what I mean? I really don’t. In the House Kirsten Gillibrand had a 100% rating from the NRA. Gabbard merely said she’d talk to the NRA President, analogizing him to the Syrian dictator! She didn’t sign the assault weapons ban in 2018, which was a smart move if she was running for President. Being a left wing pro-gun Democrat was a thing like five minutes ago. Sanders, Dean, etc. Has the party moved that far left? > I think Gabbard is horrible but I'm not interested in selling you on that. It’s not that I’m not sold, it’s that I don’t even understand the argument.