6 ms·
How is a suspension that long even vaguely appropriate? At some point the school is just abandoning the kid and their future. If the kid did it there needs to
by lostlogin 5y ago
How is a suspension that long even vaguely appropriate? At some point the school is just abandoning the kid and their future.
If the kid did it there needs to be a punishment, but surely education is a key part of what needs to happen?
- Zak 5y agoIt's likely connected to school shootings. A student making threats results in long-term suspension or expulsion as well as criminal charges for the protection of other students (a suspended student who shows up at school can be arrested for trespassing without any other suspicious behavior). The lack of criminal charges in this case suggests the evidence isn't strong enough to support them, and it seems to me that similar standards should be applied to a long-term suspension or expulsion.
- Spooky23 5y agoSounds like a big school district with administration that is a bunch of assholes. Making disciplinary referrals to a police officer is gross. My sister had a classmate who ended up with a felony conviction for counterfeiting money, using a low-end HP OfficeJet and glueing two sides together as a joke. It was absurd, to the point the sentencing judge made his displeasure known.
- deathhand 5y agoThere is a system and it will be used. It is important for everyone reading this that either takes part or directs their own little systems to ask the question, what is the ramifications of this being abused? This can relate to cyber security, social fabric, and school systems. We all don't have to play along and it's important for everyone to stand up for what is right. (Says the misfit who befriended their SRO[school resource officer])
- Spooky23 5y agoAgreed. My beef is the chickenshit school people who escalate things out of laziness or malice. Heck, the teacher’s doubts made it into the article.
- exporectomy 5y agoThat's not the school(district)'s problem. It's the law and justice system's problem. That should be fixed instead of just hoping that nobody ever reports kids for joke counterfeiting. What if a classmate had called them instead of the school? I think the police should deal with violence in school. Kids get assaulted at school in ways that would get the offender locked up if it happened in the street. School is somehow a law-free zone for a lot of offences.
- hellomyguys 5y agoPolice are already a big presence in many schools in the US already.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> It was absurd, to the point the sentencing judge made his displeasure known. The judge is free to dismiss the charge, if he thinks it's absurd. How did she end up with a conviction?
- chmod775 5y agoIf it's a crime, it's a crime. Judges have to choose the sentence they give from within the bounds of the law. They can't willy-nilly decide not to sentence someone - they merely can hand out the minimum possible sentence (which may be no sentence at all) after finding the defendant guilty. If the law is stupid and assholes are abusing it, there's little a judge can do[1] - unless they happen to be a constitutional court and can declare laws unconstitutional. You'd need someone with the power to pardon or commute, which are powers generally only held by high ranking members of the executive. [1] This depends on the country, but in some places judges are given greater freedom to interpret the 'intent' of the law as opposed to going by the letter. Sure, the kid technically made fake money, even if it was really shitty, but it clearly wasn't the intent of the law to criminalize what that kid did.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThat is not true at all. Judges definitely do have the individual power to dismiss charges against someone; I have personally seen it done.
- chmod775 5y ago> Judges definitely do have the individual power to dismiss charges against someone; I have personally seen it done. I did not say they didn't. They may do so - may meaning they are allowed to - if it is obvious that there was no crime or there is insufficient evidence or there was a procedural error etc. (rules for this can vary greatly). In this case that does not apply at all though. Don't you think if the judge could just dismiss the charge they would have done so? Do you honestly believe you've got a better handle on the legalities of this than the person whose job this is?
- kaliszad 5y agoWell, not going to such a school might be more beneficial in the right family setting than going. Also, if you think that 3 months out of 12 or so years of schooling will "abandon the kid and their future" than we should probably add years you have to go to school to minimise the effect of aggregated absence because of e.g. illness. Of course, 3 months of missed school are probably below any kind of measurability and natural and familiar influences are going to have a much higher bearing. The kid is also probably not going to stay in a vacuum even when at home, it is definitely going to learn something on its own too. Maybe not something that will get it a better grade but most likely something rather useful in the real life.
- GeneralMayhem 5y ago> we should probably add years you have to go to school to minimise the effect of aggregated absence because of e.g. illness. How many sick days did you take as a kid? I'm pretty sure I didn't get close to 3 months in aggregate until I was out for a full month at once with mono in college. Missing three months all at once is very unusual and disruptive. Anyway, the problem here is not the actual lost learning - we know that actual academic education is spotty at best in American schools. The problem is that relatively small disturbances to the happy-path of social and bureaucratic progression as a kid can have outsize effects because of path dependence, and he's now tagged as A Problem Child forever. He will never, ever get the benefit of the doubt. He'll likely have subtle social difficulties because kids will look at him funny. To the extent that school is meant as a gentle introduction to how to deal with other people in the "real" world, his is pretty well fucked.
- kaliszad 5y agoThe authorized absence rate seems to be just above 3 %: https://explore-education-statistics.service.gov.uk/find-statistics/pupil-absence-in-schools-in-england-autumn-term https://explore-education-statistics.service.gov.uk/find-sta... which amount to ~ 3 days of absence per term/ ~ 6 days per year. 6 * 12 = 72, which is quite a bit more than three months in aggregate (it is more like 3,5 months). This is in the UK but it is probably reasonably similar elsewhere. Maybe it will "be a problem child" forever. Maybe it will actually learn to be more assertive thanks to that and either end up in jail or as a high performing employee or founder. Nobody knows and it really depends. The happy-path of social and bureaucratic progression as a kid could be to develop some thick skin early. The school in the general case is a very harsh introduction to the real world. More often than not, kids are mean to each other. Either you develop some elbows or you are generally loved or you like most kids somehow make it through. Either way, it could be, the parents of that kid would or will move to a different city altogether and socially start from scratch.