3 ms·
It can be a pet peeve of mine as well, but at the same time, there are statements that require no empirical analysis to “prove”. Like, would you disagree that w
by kaba0 5y ago
It can be a pet peeve of mine as well, but at the same time, there are statements that require no empirical analysis to “prove”. Like, would you disagree that writing a program in brainfuck is more error-prone than Java?
But even in medicine, probably the area with the most extensive empiricism (we have insane amounts of data on mouses and humans), there are claims that won’t ever get to the point of doing a study on. There are stupid things that get tested, eg homeopathy (it has plenty of studies showing it is quack), but I think noone would say it is irresponsible for a doctor to claim that hand healing over a gun shot is not effective, even without direct evidence.
Of course there are surprising findings everywhere and as other commenters wrote, especially in low level optimizations the “obviously slower” solution can easily win. But I would wager that C is so terrible as a language with so little protection from even trivial mistypings, no real abstraction power requiring text-based macros that simply should have never existed to begin with, and the worst of all, not even goddamn namespaces making everything’s name indecipherable. On the other hand, I’m not necessarily bought that Rust’s borrow checker is the best way for handling memory-related errors, for example a syntactically better-than-C language like C++, or Zig might reduce memory bugs just as much, we don’t know.