Perhaps the problem is that these things do not have definitive answers. Reality is extremely complex, with many interfacing chaotic systems. Why would we exp

Perhaps the problem is that these things do not have definitive answers. Reality is extremely complex, with many interfacing chaotic systems. Why would we expect a single answer to work in every instance? What if there isn't a perfect diet for everyone, but each person can find the one that works best for them? I don't think it's surprising that there isn't a definitive answer to what the effects of a carrington event might be. The analysis required to provide such an answer would have such vast complexity that it's likely not worth the effort. All we have is our best guesses, based on informed and deliberate inquiry. I don't think we can reasonably expect anything more than that.