4 ms·
This is the big problem with the 'marketplace of ideas' and the notion that better education and dialog will fix everything. In a small marketplace, like a farm
by anigbrowl 6y ago
This is the big problem with the 'marketplace of ideas' and the notion that better education and dialog will fix everything. In a small marketplace, like a farmer's market, that's true. Also, markets based on a fungible commodity work OK as long as there's standardization of the product and conditions of perfect competition or something close to them obtain.
But in most marketplaces advertising is a dominant force, and advertising power is not a function of product quality; you can market a bad product successfully. There are standards of truth in advertising, but they're loose and poorly enforced, the burden of evaluation falls on the consumer. Additionally, tribalist behavior builds up around products to a certain extent, as buyers of product X who dislike hearing it's good or crap push back on such claims, for varying reasons. Where these differences are purely aesthetic that doesn't matter much, but where they're functional a objectively better product can lose out against a one from a dishonest competitor or one with an irrationally loyal following. A problem for both producers and consumers is that it's more expensive to refute a false claim than to make it, so bad actors are incentivized to lie and lock int he advantage; it's arguably cheaper to apologize if caught out than to forgo the profitable behavior, as exemplified in the aphorism 'it's easier to ask forgiveness than permission.'
We see the results with problems like the OP and also in things like debates about public health, vaccine safety, climate change, and many other political issues. It's profitable to lie, a significant number of people have no problem doing it, the techniques of doing so have been repeatedly refined and weaponized, and those who rely on or simply prefer truth end up at a significant economic disadvantage. don't make the mistake of thinking this is problem confined to the niche world of academic journals.