3 ms·
> She adds, “The Greeks were obsessed with being Greeks,” considering all those who didn’t speak the language “barbarians.” But "barbarian" meant something lik
by tgv 5y ago
> She adds, “The Greeks were obsessed with being Greeks,” considering all those who didn’t speak the language “barbarians.”
But "barbarian" meant something like "speaking another language".
- dylanwisor 5y agoIt’s a tricky sentence to parse, but I think the divide between those who spoke Greek and those who didn’t was what she intended to communicate, not that they affixed the modern connotations of the word “barbarian” to non-Greek speakers.
- tgv 5y agoI'm pretty sure that was the intention conveyed there, but I'll be damned if I can find the quote. It seems to have disappeared from the page.
- coldtea 5y agoYes, a modern close to the spirit of the original translation would be "blah-blah-rian", "yak-yak-rian" or "indicipherable-rian". They however had no ideas about the inferiority of those (except that they preferred their own lifestyles which considered free-er). Ancient slavery also was not about race, but about e.g. losing the battle and being caught or debt. Greeks could be (and often were) slaves to other Greeks.
- cryptonector 5y ago"barbarian" == "people who say bar bar bar bar bar" == "people who speak gibberish" "barbarbar" ~ "blahblahblah"
- YeGoblynQueenne 5y ago>> "barbarbar" ~ "blahblahblah" I don't think this is right. "Blah blah" implies someone who is overly talkative. "bar bar" [1] is an onomatopoieia of someone speaking a non-Greek language, like "arf arf" is for a dog. I'm not even sure it has the meaning of "speaking gibberish" that you give it. I think it was literally just the way that some ancient language that was not Greek sounded to Greek ears. A bit like with the Swedish chef in Muppet show. _________ [1] Actually, "var var". In Greek it's "βάρβαρος", pronounced "varvaros".
- mrslave 5y agoI thought this originated with the Romans because of the high frequency use of barbarians to refer to Germans to the north that couldn't be conquered and were often a thorn in the side of Rome. But this could be a borrowed word, and my perceived definition to describe the Germans is just the long-lasting influence of the Roman empire. Did the Greeks use it frequently to describe any one people in particular?
- zvr 5y agoNo, it was used for everyone speaking a non-Greek language. In Homer there is no "barbarian"; only "barbar-speaking". But by the time of Aeschylus, it was a noun denoting people speaking non-Greek. There was also the corresponding verb that meant "speak a foreign language" but also "speak broken Greek / make lots of errors speaking (Greek)". In Roman times, "barbarian" meant anyone who was not Roman or Greek.
- wolfretcrap 5y agoBarbarian is simply someone who does not (some might say, they don't because they simply cannot) verbally articulate deep thoughts and views on a topic. It does not mean such people do not posses intelligence for this, it's just a cultural difference they might choose to keep their thoughts to themselves or see no point in convincing others through discourse if the power is established through sword.