2 ms·
I commented this above, but I think it's relevant here. It's odd that I hear people who say "Oh, in prison, they're safe from society." That's not true histori
by gjsman-1000 5y ago
I commented this above, but I think it's relevant here.
It's odd that I hear people who say "Oh, in prison, they're safe from society." That's not true historically. Some of the most dangerous people in history were imprisoned, multiple times, and not killed for fear of public anger - only to get out of prison and wreak havoc.
Hitler was found guilty of treason, but was given a more humane 5 years in prison instead of the death penalty that would have historically been applied to treasonous people. He wrote Mein Kampf, got out of prison, started World War II, and killed millions.
Stalin was exiled to Siberia multiple times for his crimes including bank robbery, kidnappings, and extortion instead of being given death. He came back to Russia for the February Revolution, overthrew the Russian empire, started the Gulag system, and caused the deaths of millions.
For all we know, the Unabomber is in prison right now, but what happens if he escaped? It is not historically impossible, or even implausible, that he couldn't repeat history like many revolutionaries who were arrested, got out, and took over.
The point is more that there is zero guarantee historically that people in prison are completely safely isolated from society. And for that reason, let's say 90% of convictions to death (considering only 22 people died in 2019) were accurate and 2 were wrong. Considering how extremely dangerous historically and in reality the criminals being convicted to death are considered to be, it's a necessary evil to ensure justice and safety for the regular citizen.
For that reason, will some innocent people be sentence to death? Unlikely considering how much crime is required, but it is possible. But just because that could potentially happen doesn't invalidate the death penalty. If we invalidated everything because it could affect _just one_ person, why not have the police be able to break down doors at will because just one kidnapped person might be found? Why not throw out encryption on our phones because just one child molester might be found?