2 ms·
You’ve got some reading up to do on behavioral economics. Humans (real ones, not model economic actors) can’t and don’t make optimal decisions except in very sp
by baq 5y ago
You’ve got some reading up to do on behavioral economics. Humans (real ones, not model economic actors) can’t and don’t make optimal decisions except in very special circumstances.
- gruez 5y agoThat doesn't answer my question at all.
- baq 5y agoOf course. Never meant to, just pointed to a direction that you seem to be unaware of.
- gruez 5y ago>Never meant to, just pointed to a direction that you seem to be unaware of. What gave you that impression? In my initial comment I acknowledged the concept of excusing suboptimal decision making due to "psychology of decision making when poor and struggling". How is that different than what you're saying?
- baq 5y agoYou call it 'excusing'.
- gruez 5y agoThat seems like the right characterization to me? Definition from wiktionary: >3. (transitive) To provide an excuse for; to explain, with the aim of alleviating guilt or negative judgement. Earlier in the thread there was definitely a tone of negative judgement. ie. "people show up all the time with a litany of complaints and a litany of awful, awful budget mistakes they have no interest in fixing"
- baq 5y agoNegative judgment is exactly what is off mark. Real humans make mistakes. No whys or buts or excepts. They just do and they shouldn't be blamed for what is essentially being human. IOW people can't be reasonably expected to make rational, self-interested choices. (It's actually amazing this is almost a Nobel-prize worthy observation in economics. This is psychology 101.) If you ask why or what kinds of mistakes they make, now that is where the books go deep. Suffice to say those mistakes are not unpredictable and people can be nudged to make a better (dare I say correct) choice.
- gruez 5y ago>Negative judgment is exactly what is off mark. Right, but I'm not the person giving the negative judgement. I specifically recognize the possibility of "excusing" them (ie. not negatively judging them) in some cases, and ask whether they should be excused in some cases or all cases. After this long conversation it appears you believe in the latter. Is this correct?