4 ms·
The "fake news" problem on Social Media is a huge problem. I'm not talking about arguable differences of opinion, I'm talking about baldfaced lies. Objectively
by fortran77 5y ago
The "fake news" problem on Social Media is a huge problem. I'm not talking about arguable differences of opinion, I'm talking about baldfaced lies. Objectively "fake" news.
For example reverse-image searches of bombed out buildings or dead children that purport to be from a conflict yesterday were revealed to be from the Syrian Civil War from 6 years ago. And these images were re-tweeted by Americans, some in positions of responsibility. I'm all for free speech, but I feel that people and platforms should be held accountable for actions like this, when they involve objectively false news. False by anyone's definition of false.
- beagle3 5y agoIt is occasionally clear cut. But what if those same pictures are tweeted, with only a vague text like "This is how war looks like"? I've seen this in the last week, specifically with 6-year old Syrian civil war pictures, and placed strategically among tweets about recent israel/palestine war. Some of the replies to the poster were "hey, this is old pictures" to which they replied "I never claimed otherwise". Is this fake news by any objective measure? If you somehow detect (and disallow) provably fake news, it just means that it will shift to deliberately vague statements, strategically placed among true statements, so that they cannot be faulted as "false". I think the problem is inherently unsolvable.
- DangitBobby 5y agoWhile this sort of "memeing" is unfortunate and probably unsolvable, the sort of fake news that invents or even heavily skews facts to match a narrative could be detectible.
- CharlesW 5y ago> I think the problem is inherently unsolvable. Most of the world's problems are inherently unsolvable if you treat solved/unsolved as a binary condition. That doesn't mean that there's no obligation to help mitigate at least some of the negative effects that technology (and I'm not singling out computing) enables or amplifies.
- beagle3 5y agoI don't consider this a binary condition. There's an inherent balance on information dissemination, much like any "true positive / false positive". We might not be at the optimum, but I don't think we're far off either. It also depends on your priors, of course. We might disagree on whether only "authority approved" data can be disseminated, and about specific authorities (gov, ny times, snopes, individuals, ...), and whether precision or speed is more important - you can delay any tweet for a year at which time it can be verified. That will considerably reduce the "fake" factor, but at a cost I am not willing to pay.
- fortran77 5y agoAs we see from the downvotes, people feel that 100% fake pictures are fine if they feel their agenda is worth promoting. The fact that people here on Hacker News feel that way means there's no solution to this problem. When you're dealing with pure evil, no rational appeal to not spreading lies is going to help.
- hooande 5y agoThis is inconsequential. People ARE dying, that part isn't made up. It would be fake news if there had been no casualties and pictures from other wars were used to assert that there had been. Fake news is largely defined by context and degree. Details can matter, a lot, in specific situations. This isn't one of those situations.
- tryonenow 5y agoIt is absolutely consequential if you give any priority to credibility. It is consequential when such images from other conflicts are used to exaggerate or otherwise mislead - and if a journalist is willing to use unrelated material then all of their work is suspect. Integrity is black and white. You write truthfully or you don't - and frankly most outlets today don't. But they'll be the first to tell you that the other side has a fake news problem.
- fortran77 5y agoI think this attitude is terrible. Facts matter. You think lies are OK, and that's not right.