4 ms·
I'm always amazed at the amount of drama in communities like this, given that the absolute value of these channels tends to be so low. I mean, we're not talkin
by ajross 5y ago
I'm always amazed at the amount of drama in communities like this, given that the absolute value of these channels tends to be so low.
I mean, we're not talking about someone hijacking an ad-rich youtube channel here. This is the "##hntop" channel. It reposts top news from... this very site. It's something anyone reading this comment can get for free by pressing the back button on their browser.
And yet someone still decides it's worth their effort to kick an admin (or I guess in this case force the channel registration) and steal it? Good grief.
- JackGreyhat 5y agoPretty much makes it even worse.
- mmastrac 5y agoOften lowest stakes and highest drama go hand-in-hand.
- sidpatil 5y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sayre%27s_law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sayre%27s_law
- simias 5y agoI feel the same way, but I think it's really simple: people who care enough about being mods to become one are the same people who are likely to let it get to their head. Mod drama on reddit for instance is fairly incredible in scope and dedication. For some people being a mod seems to be effectively a full time activity and getting to mod as many subreddits as possible an objective, regardless of whether you have any particular interest in the sub in question. It's absolutely baffling to me because you'd have to pay me to do that job, but clearly some people thrive on this type of power.
- dimmke 5y agoI had the same thought I think it’s super funny I’m reading about IRC drama on here in 2021
- brianberns 5y agoI don’t know anything about IRC, but it seems more benign that that: the person who ran ##hntop abandoned it for another platform, so the guy who runs its sister channel, ##hnnew, recreated it, because they naturally go together. Calling this “abuse” seems like a stretch to me.
- FeepingCreature 5y agoYou can register channels, the point of which is exactly that this sort of thing cannot happen, or at least not trivially. Of course, when you run the network, you can do what you want. But then, that's the point of the move.
- brianberns 5y agoYes, I can see that it’s a technical violation of the policy. On the other hand, OP explicitly abandoned the channel and then cried “abuse” when the administrator stepped in to resuscitate it. And now this very tiny tempest in a teapot is at the top of HN for us all to gawk at.
- staz 5y agothe concern is more about the impersonation. It's like you had mysite.com, decided to rename it to a new domain and so put a redirect. And then the CEO of the DNS authority decided to take your domain for himself, put a copy of your previous site on it and pretended that you never moved it in the first place.
- brianberns 5y agoIt’s nothing like that. If you want a modern analogy, it’s like the moderators of a subreddit abandoning it, and the reddit admins deciding to keep it going anyway. It violates the expected wall between moderators and admins, but it’s hardly theft or impersonation.
- 5y ago
- swiley 5y agoThis is why expecting names (nicks and channels) on IRC to have any permanent meaning causes problems. The protocol was not designed for this (and I question weather it can be done in any reasonable way without a "benevolent dictator" kind of authority.)
- salawat 5y agoDNS has the same problem amusingly.
- marcan_42 5y agoNot just someone, the "owner" of the network. In my opinion, this is a graver offense than, say, someone using an exploit or similar to take over a channel. This person is supposed to be in a position of power and trust.