3 ms·
Here[0] is a paper going into some detail, comparing human language with animal communication systems. The mostly define the difference as related to compositio
by tsimionescu 6y ago
Here[0] is a paper going into some detail, comparing human language with animal communication systems. The mostly define the difference as related to composition: in animal communication, each "word" almost always carries individual meaning, while multiple "word" together carry all the meanings together (the paper also discusses cases where simple composition has in fact been identified). In human language, the meaning of a combination of words depends not just on the words themselves, but on the way they are combined as well.
To show an example: if you give me some bananas and I say "I like bananas but not these ones", it means I don't like the bananas you gave me. But a bonobo or dog "saying" some equivalent of "like" and "banana" would always mean that they like them (according to the paper, they could also "say" something like "not-like", "banana" showing some simple compositionality).
Another important observation (that is not found in the paper) is that animals have never been observed to "discuss" about abstract things or counter-factuals, which is what I mean when I say that their communication is quasi-automatic. For example, a monkey will only "say" "leopard" if it notices a leopard, or if it hears another monkey "say" "leopard" (or, most sophisticatedly, if it wants to elicit the leopard response from the other monkeys, e.g. to steal some food). But there is never a "discussion" about leopards that are not present and that does not cause the monkeys to have a leopard response.
Essentially animal communication is much more similar to our non-verbal queues, such as moaning or gasping or screaming, rather than to verbal communication. It can be more sophisticated than that, especially in primates, whales, and dolphins, encoding some information about social relationships, but 1 year old children already display much more complex language abilities than the most sophisticated animal.
[0] https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rstb.2019.0062 https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rstb.2019.006...
- marcus_holmes 6y agothat's interesting, thanks