3 ms·
> “Given this prediction, we ask ‘why are non-replicable papers accepted for publication in the first place?’” Obviously, because journals don't attempt replic
by crazygringo 6y ago
> “Given this prediction, we ask ‘why are non-replicable papers accepted for publication in the first place?’”
Obviously, because journals don't attempt replication, nor should they.
A study will only have replication by another researcher/team after it's been published. Or not, in which case that's publishable as well.
This is how science works and is supposed to work.
The problem should rather be: why are journals accepting papers with citations to debunked papers that don't also cite the debunking papers?
I've had plenty of friends have a paper get sent back for revisions because it was missing a newer citation. This should be a major responsibility of reviewers. So why aren't peer reviewers staying on top of the literature?
- rscho 6y ago> This should be a major responsibility of reviewers. So why aren't peer reviewers staying on top of the literature? Perhaps because reviewing is unpaid work, both in the financial and academic sense?
- crazygringo 6y agoI definitely don't disagree with that!