3 ms·
When will we stop fetishizing and lionizing "job creation"? The ideal business would employ zero people, have zero expenses, and make a 100% profit margin. Fro
by triceratops 5y ago
When will we stop fetishizing and lionizing "job creation"? The ideal business would employ zero people, have zero expenses, and make a 100% profit margin.
From a purely business perspective, every job created is an inefficiency. No one sets out to create jobs when they start a business. They set out to make money and create products or services of value - in that order. Employing people is an unfortunate side-effect of that.
- krapp 5y ago>When will we stop fetishizing and lionizing "job creation"? When it stops getting politicians elected. No one wants to vote for the person who assures them they will do everything in their power to put them out of work and transfer their value directly to shareholders.
- WalterBright 5y agoThe beauty of the free market is that by pursuing selfish interests, people wind up benefiting others as well. The failure of collective markets stems from nobody has figured out how to get people to stop acting selfishly.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> The beauty of the free market is that by pursuing selfish interests, people wind up benefiting others as well The free market does not encourage pursuing action where the benefits accrue to people outside of the transaction, but it does encourage actions where the harms are so externalized. A hypothetical optimally regulated market systems with Pigovian taxes and subsidies to internalize externalities would in theory have the effect that pursuit of private gain would at least not be adverse to the common interest, but that’s very far from a “free market”.
- WalterBright 5y agoInternalizing the externalities via taxation is very much a free market approach.
- dragonwriter 5y agoA market is “free” to the extent the government does not intervene to regulate, promote, or discourage behavior. Pigovian taxes and subsidies are a market-based approach to regulation, not a free market one (which would be an oxymoron.)
- WalterBright 5y agoExternalities are costs dumped on others who didn't agree. Hence taxing externalities and using the revenue for the common good corrects for that. Hence it is free market.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Externalities are costs dumped on others who didn't agree Yes. > Hence taxing externalities and using the revenue for the common good corrects for that That's the argument for Pigovian taxes and subsidies. The typical “free market” counterargument is that the government taxing and spending for the common good to correct that: (1) violates consent and does not take into account whether and how much the individual “beneficiaries” would be willing to pay when taxing the public and spending for Pigovian subsidies, (2) does not compensate for lack of consent or compensate the individuals harmed what they would be willing to accept to consent to the inflicted harms when collecting and spending pigovian taxes. And, therefore, that the correct policy is for individuals who would benefit to subsidize third party action in place of Pigovian subsidies, and seek individual remedy, e.g. via the courts, for unconsented negative externalities. > Hence it is free market. That it compensates for what sone people see as a problem in unregulated markets doesn’t make it “free market”.
- triceratops 5y agoI agree 100% and I wasn't trying to contrast free markets and collective markets. I just dislike the virtue signaling around "job creation". It's not virtuous at all. We fail to acknowledge that "job creation" benefits the business, because it helps them earn revenue or reduce costs. Ain't nothing noble about hiring someone to do a job. It's a business, not a charity.
- ipaddr 5y agoNot true at all. Some employees can create profit if you could hire more of these employees you jump. Sales people are easy to measure, if you could hire 100 or 1000 people who make double what they cost you do. If you want some other area of your company strong you invest in that area. An lawyer during a period where the public is sueing you pays for itself. Hiring a developer to fix a login issue saves refunds. A lot of jobs seems less important but they provide support and are net positives. Having a server guy means you have a working server. Having a marketing guy means new leads are coming in. Having more sales people means converting more of those leads. The ineffiency comes when you have too many people in one department waiting on an understaffed area in some other part of the business.
- triceratops 5y ago> Some employees can create profit if you could hire more of these employees you jump And that's my point. Every hire a business makes is to increase revenue or reduce costs. Employment benefits the worker, but it also benefits the business. If a business could get the work of that employee done without hiring that employee, it would happily do so. If two parties partake in a trade that has mutual benefit, why is either of them "noble"? Why aren't we calling the worker "noble" for providing the business with their skills and time?
- unishark 5y agoYour idea of business and what entrepreneurs want is simplistic. You must know it will be easy to find people who don't fit blanket statements like this. Even if you think this is the natural inclination of the public corporation, not all companies have to go public and not all investors in public companies care about nothing the company does besides make profit. It's a world of humans we operate in, not some kind of logical optimal point.
- triceratops 5y agoDo you disagree with my central thesis that businesses employ people almost entirely to increase revenue or cut costs? The presence of a few sinecures in some companies doesn't change this basic fact.
- unishark 5y agoYes I disagree and not because of people slipping through the cracks or something. I was referring to people and companies who have a mission. For example to help the blind to see or connect the world. Or the many many small businesses who seek to improve their local region and employ people. Perhaps you're thinking of the pressures on management of the fortune 500 or something, but that's a far cry from sweeping claims like "almost entirely" or "every job". If you want a job at a place with more of a conscience or whatever, they are all over the place. Especially among startups.
- triceratops 5y ago> For example to help the blind to see or connect the world. And if they could lower costs by employing fewer people, they'd have more money to spend on helping the blind see or connect the world. Alternatively, they employ more people because they believe it will allow them to help more blind people or connect the world better. The point is, they don't hire people for the sake of giving them a paycheck. There's something of equal value expected of those people in return. > Or the many many small businesses who seek to...employ people Which ones? Which business has "employ people" as an objective to be maximized? How does it even manage to stay in business working like that? (Note: I'm not talking about businesses that make serious sacrifices to minimize job losses in a downturn; that's praiseworthy. I'm talking about businesses that have headcount as a primary metric of success.) And if pure job creation is soooo morally good, how do you feel about a government job guarantee? They have that under a number of communist or socialist systems. So is communism or socialism morally superior to capitalism? Serious question: if you hire a babysitter for date night with your partner, do you feel virtuous about creating employment? Or do you see it as an exchange of some money for a service? If you do feel virtuous, you should re-think that. Another serious question: is automation immoral? It puts people out of work, after all.