5 ms·
One my pet peeves is when the local NPR station will advocate some position or policy based on a recent small study (usually by/at some state school), sometimes
by mc32 5y ago
One my pet peeves is when the local NPR station will advocate some position or policy based on a recent small study (usually by/at some state school), sometimes they'll couch it saying it's not peer reviewed, it's preliminary, or something, but it's too late, they already planted the seed, had their talking point -all with a study to back up their position and listeners just go along with it.
- jtsiskin 5y agoStart up idea - run hundreds of “preliminary studies” with small sample sizes, then sell any of the p-hacked results to marketing or news groups. Want a story about how milk boosts intelligence? Want a story for how a standing desk leads to promotions? We have it all
- daenz 5y agoI will assume best intentions that this is a sarcastic suggestion, because it is pretty evil and socially irresponsible otherwise :)
- fighterpilot 5y agoIt is but it might finally pop the bubble around "study says X" in the public's mind
- visarga 5y agoThen people turn away and stop believing in global warming and vaccines.
- iamadog2 5y agoOr they develop the critical thinking skills to realize that science is 95% failing and 5% "we don't reject the alternative". It is not absolute, and certainly the scientists themselves are deeply flawed being that they're human. But here's the thing, people don't have time for this. They have work, bills, home and car maintenance, groceries, kids, friends, a slew of media to consume, recreation on top of it - and they're all dying. So it doesn't matter who says what, they're going to pick the dilute politicized version of the results that their team supports and run with it regardless of what the nigh-unreadable highly specialized papers say. Orwell said it well "I believe that this instinct to perpetuate useless work is, at bottom, simply fear of the mob. The mob (the thought runs) are such low animals that they would be dangerous if they had leisure; it is safer to keep them too busy to think." And those who do elect the burden of extracurricular mental activity aren't given much in the way of options in any case. What are they to do, disseminate the material to their friends, co-workers, children - quite probably the very same population as mentioned above, weighted with the ceaseless demands of reality? To what end? Chinese whispers? It's better to have them say, "I don't know, I'm not convinced either way." A construal which is developed from adequately exercised critical skills. But that's another discussion about perverse social conditioning no doubt evolved from the deployment of poorly understood technique compounded by its acceptance as custom in education - I'm speaking of course about grading and student assessment. Nobody wants to be stupid at the very least, and professing one's ignorance is construed as an admission of guilt.
- taneq 5y agoBut why use your company when they could just... make it up? :P
- whatshisface 5y agoThat market segment is already completely satisfied with existing options. The "hundreds of studies" are done for free by academics without meta-epistemic-scruples, and the selling to marketing groups is done for free by marketers without epistemic scruples.
- gruez 5y agoso basically this: https://xkcd.com/882/ https://xkcd.com/882/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mjburgess 5y agoThat's status quo It's called the "research grant system"
- TimPC 5y agoTerrible start-up idea that has a better revenue model. Sell the experiment design to politically motivated organizations that want certain outcomes in the public sphere. Hack your way to results. Give to media for free.
- dagw 5y agoThat already exists and is called a "think tank".
- baby 5y agoThat’s why this whole journal peer review thing is bullshit. There’s a better solution: read pre prints and let people rank/discuss them as organic peer review.
- remolacha 5y agohttps://www.researchhub.com/ https://www.researchhub.com/
- dr_kiszonka 5y agoThis is interesting. My first reaction is that the upvotes there are not a measure of quality because, I assume, they are based mainly on titles and abstracts. But I will try to use that site a bit more, so thanks for sharing.
- crystalmeph 5y ago“We did it Reddit” stands starkly counter to your recommendation. I don’t know what the answer is, and I’ve been worried for a while that we are putting blind faith in “science” which just lines up with our preferred worldview. Maybe the answer is simply to use science, however it is performed, to inform, not guide, policy, and always keep in mind that what science believes has a non-zero chance of being politically-driven itself.