6 ms·
> To some people (I am not one of them at all, but I understand the argument) any abortion is literally murder, and it as a sincerely held belief as the recent
by tshaddox 5y ago
> To some people (I am not one of them at all, but I understand the argument) any abortion is literally murder, and it as a sincerely held belief as the recent movements like BLM and #metoo were.
This as well as other parts of your comment seem to imply that you believe the sincerity or intensity with which one holds a particular belief is one of the most important factors in the merits of that belief. I personally do not think this is the case.
- bhupy 5y agoThis comment seems to imply that certain beliefs (ostensibly your own) are objective truths/facts that hold special merit. This is simply not the case.
- Kalium 5y agoI think you might find that those you consider your deepest ideological foes would wholeheartedly agree with you on precisely this point.
- tjs8rj 5y agoI think sincerity is a short hand to cut through partisanship. You believe what you believe sincerely, likely because you find it backed in truth / agreeing with your morals and best intentions. If we assume all humans generally back their sincere beliefs because they find them truthful / backed by their values, the conclusion is that you either have different information or different morals. You can either assume everyone who disagrees with you is evil or stupid, or you can probably more accurately recognize that someone who disagrees with you, especially if they also live in America, has access to just as much info as you, has access to similar resources, probably isn’t evil: so the conclusion is that they are acting in good faith but with different morals. Sincerity is a short hand for the fact that most humans are intelligent like you, and most humans in your proximity have access like you, and arent evil, so the result is that they are much more similar than you than you think but with different experiences. It means you can cut through to the root questions instead of using far worse shorthand’s than sincerity - like “they voted the other way so they much be evil and hellbent on destroying my way of life”.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lanstin 5y agoI tend to believe that about some portion, say 20% to 50% of what I believe is not accurate. I can’t be sure which portions are wrong, so I try to stay close to the evidence and open to correction when communicating. Sincerity is fine but it isn’t a replacement for being open and humble and kind.
- jasonwatkinspdx 5y agoI am very familiar with anti abortionist activists views due to my family. My mom marched with Operation Rescue during the infamous summer in Wichita that resulted in first a bombing, then eventually a murder done by shooting a doctor in the middle of a church service. There is a deep dishonesty in everything they say. They trot out the abortion is murder phrase constantly, but their behavior reveals that their actual priority is asserting their sexual mores. They want to punish those who disagree with them. It's part of a deeper hypocrisy that forms the spine of the modern evangelical movement in the US. I remember vividly my parents describing to me God's grace as a loophole: "You need to try to do good, but so long as you accept God into your heart once you're now saved no matter what you do." This is why you see evangelicals regularly act against their own professed morals, so long as it fits the performance of being a good evangelical christian.
- refurb 5y agoDid you just paint an entire political belief based on your own personal experience?
- jasonwatkinspdx 5y agoYes, because I spent the first two decades of my life trapped with a very wide variety of these people. To be clear, I'm specifically talking about the overt activist community. You have no idea how many hours I was forced to watch cravenly dishonest videos about reproductive biology. It may be anecdotal, but I believe the characterization I'm offering of these people is universal to that activist community and entirely accurate. I would gently suggest you not be so dismissive with a cliched reply like "anecdotes aren't data" which isn't particularly relevant here.
- refurb 5y ago“I am very familiar with anti-abortion activists”. You share an anecdote then claim it applies to everyone?
- 5y ago
- betwixthewires 5y agoThat's obvious from your arguments. You think that the most important factor in the merits of a belief is whether you believe in it or not.