4 ms·
Good! It's about time that our industry's monopoly of the ages is put to bed. Apple put us in the kettle and slowly turned up the heat. They delivered good har
by echelon 6y ago
Good! It's about time that our industry's monopoly of the ages is put to bed.
Apple put us in the kettle and slowly turned up the heat. They delivered good hardware, good software, but at the same time demanded that nobody else have the ability to run JIT, other runtimes, first-class web, browsers, marketplaces, etc. Over time, Apple rose to 50% of the market, all the while exacting complete control and taxing all market activities.
Unfortunately, iPhone is now responsible for a majority of its users' business activities. It's the single plane of control between a user and their banking, commerce, communication, entertainment, and social lives.
We didn't allow this level of control with Microsoft in the 90's and 00's, and there's no reason we should allow the increased scope of control that Apple has now.
They need to lose the App Store.
They need to have an open platform.
They can't run Apple Pay.
Other browsers and JIT runtimes need to be allowed. Marketplaces, too.
This needs to happen to Google as well.
We don't pay the electric company for every app we install. We don't pay UPS for our Netflix subscriptions. Apple isn't providing any additional economic value. They're a tax, and that's it. They're also an impediment to repairing our own devices. It has to stop, and they have to start playing fair.
- kaiju0 6y agoThey would just stop making the phone.
- echelon 6y ago> They would just stop making the phone. Stop making their high margin hardware that integrates into paid Apple services? The same phone that works with other massively popular Apple hardware, such as Air Pods? Extremely doubtful. Apple will not cut off their nose to spite their face. Maybe you have less faith in Apple than I do. I believe they can succeed enormously without their monopoly. They make great products. Microsoft managed just fine (look at their market cap!) edit: I'm confused. Are the downvotes from Apple fans that think the hardware sucks without the monopoly? And that Apple can't survive without it?
- StreamBright 6y agoHN is just a massive downvote crew nowadays without any arguments. Since the karma system does not penalize this behavior it is widespread.
- fxtentacle 6y agoOr they'll loudly whine and then follow their orders like Microsoft did back in the day.
- slver 6y agoGetting short-term compliance is the easy part. But the hard part is calculating how this changes the business incentives of a company and how they adapt to this compliance over time. What orders did Microsoft follow in specific, what are you referring about? Let's see how this has actually impacted their business today.
- mcphage 6y agoI think if Tim Cook announced he was stopping iPhone production, he would find himself unemployed by the end of the day.
- nmfisher 6y agoApple will stop making the iPhone? That's crazy talk. It's literally their most successful product line ever.
- leoedin 6y agoI agree - the service Apple are offering for recurring payments is that of a payment processor. In a competitive market that role takes 2-3% at most. And that percentage has been falling year on year as new entrants have entered the market. How does a company disrupt the Google/Apple phone duopoly? Even Microsoft spending hundreds of millions of dollars couldn't do it.
- makomk 6y agoEven on PC, where there's plenty of store competition, the only way to get much lower than 30% seems to be to seriously cut corners - Epic's own store famously lacks standard features like a shopping card, and people have had problems with buying multiple games in succession seperately triggering anti-fraud measures that stop them from doing so, so they're not exactly doing great even at the payment processing part. And they're quite openly subsidising that from their Fortnite profits as well in many ways.
- kevingadd 6y agoWhile I agree that the EGS experience is bad, I don't think this is related to the cut. It's just an immature store backed by questionable software engineering and design. There are other stores with low % cuts that don't have these issues. Itch is very cheap, for example, and developers love it. Apparently Itch is important enough that Apple and Epic kept bringing it up over and over in court. I don't know their current %s, but Humble's game sales platform (that is, for non-bundle game sales) definitely charged way less than 30% in the past.
- w7 6y agoI'm confused, don't we allow this level of control with video game consoles? (Heck Sony and Microsoft also take 30% cuts) What's the difference other than form factor?
- echelon 6y agoI message my boss on PS5 Slack and tell him I'm done for the day. I then take my PS5 to the mall, because I carry it with me to do all of my financial transactions. Later, I log onto my PS5 bank account app to check my spending limits. I check PS5 Yelp for a list of restaurants. I head out, but I'm careful to check my PS5 GPS to know where I'm headed. I fill up my car using PS5 pay, and as I leave get messages from potential romantic matches on PS5 Tinder. Of course Sony gets a cut of every transaction and there are no other options than taking your PS5 with you everywhere. Oh wait, there's Switch, Xbox, PC, Steam, Epic, GOG, ...? Lots of options for games. But what about email, finance, dating, and everything else I would do on my PS5? Gaming devices aren't general purpose computers and don't do general purpose business, communication, finance, etc. Gaming is a toy and comparatively niche industry with lots of consumer choice. The iPhone is 50% of all commerce in all industries for all Americans. Apple has locked down computing behind an iron curtain, and they're clawing away at more and more as the days go by. If the trend continues, every restaurant will be Apple (instead of Taco Bell), and you'll license your car and pay Apple by the mile. The signs you see out your window will have to pay Apple a licensing fee.
- bluescrn 6y agoGaming is unimportant. General-purpose computing is gradually being replaced by locked-down phones and tablets, and that's much more concerning.
- Google234 6y agoGeneral-purpose computing Is bigger than ever. Record PC and component sales and more open source software than ever.
- bogwog 6y agoSony/Microsoft/Nintendo get to avoid competition because games aren't important? I don't like that argument. At the end of the day, it's a company telling a consumer what they can or can't do with their own property. Sony saying you can't buy a game from anyone else is just anti-competitive BS. It isn't fair to consumers, and it isn't fair to developers. Hopefully the court rules in favor of Epic, and this case is used as precedent to go against the game console monopolies next. Also, for what it's worth, the "real" reason why game consoles aren't allowed to be jailbroken under DMCA rules (whereas phones, computers, and other devices are) is because, currently, most people only want to do it to commit piracy. Of course, that's because there are no other legitimate software vendors for that hardware. It's a chicken and egg problem.