5 ms·
This seems to me like it's setting a bad precedent. I totally understand the motivation behind something like this, but privatizing it and selling it to the hig
by smoldesu 6y ago
This seems to me like it's setting a bad precedent. I totally understand the motivation behind something like this, but privatizing it and selling it to the highest bidder not only raises ethical concerns, but also ones around how this service will be used in the first place. According to citizen it seems like these forces will respond to "disturbances", which are incredibly vaguely worded. Do I need to be in danger to call them? Or do I just need to be "disturbed"?
It seems to me like this will be used by the upper-middle class to pester their neighbors over minor annoyances, because they can afford a Citizen subscription. Imagine the poor family across the street, who gets visited by a black SUV and a group of burly looking suited security guards, likely telling them something vague about a "disturbance" that was reported.
- shmatt 6y ago> visited by a black SUV and a group of burly looking suited security guards Not very different than getting visited by a burly looking neighbor. Except some people can look weaker, or be afraid to approach their neighbor because their small stature When I had an upstairs neighbor having parties at all hours of the night, I wished there was a service where a bigger / more intimidating person would knock on their door and ask them to cut it out, instead of small and fragile looking me
- tkzed49 6y agoAnd what if I'm disturbed seeing you walk around the neighborhood, and I call some big burly men to give you a talk about it? Even if most people are reasonable, this just invites the unreasonable people to power trip with private security forces.
- ErikVandeWater 6y agoTalk? Yes.
- majormajor 6y agoDid you talk to your neighbor ever? Or did you just dream of intimidating them while fearing them without meeting them? (And you weren't afraid of potential fallout from escalating things to intimidation either way? What if they hire a BIGGER person to go knock on your door?)
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoYou're being down voted for this comment, and perhaps you could have worded it differently, but the core of your message seems completely reasonable: If you don't want to do something, you ask somebody else, if you both agree to the terms and costs you have a deal. The world can be, how should I put this, difficult a place. The contracted party might agree to not mention you. Something like: hey, I live across the street, would you mind letting me know if you're going to have music late at night because I'll just stay at my partner's place that evening, here's my number. No sweat, have a good night, here's a complimentary six pack. It doesn't take a lot of imagination to assume the best possible reading of a comment like yours. Have a lovely day.
- gowld 6y agoYour solution is to flee your own home and pay the perpetrator who is illegally disturbing the peace?
- drusepth 6y agoI've had problems with my (large) upstairs neighbor for the past year. The building repeatedly fined them, the police refused to come out, and I knocked on their door sometimes several times a day for about 9 months straight. My solution was to offer to pay them $$$ for their moving fees and, when they turned that down, I just picked up and moved to another building. That's not really much different.
- optimalsolver 6y agoOk, and if your neighbor tells your security dude to get lost, what happens then? (Assume everyone involved is armed)
- chasd00 6y ago>I wished there was a service where a bigger / more intimidating person would knock on their door and ask them to cut it out heh that's a "hired goon". This whole discussion is like standard issue organized crime and protection rackets but in app form. Too funny.
- industriousthou 6y agoYou would call in a private security force to intimidate your loud neighbors because you can't? I wonder how else that security force might be used to enforce personal preferences.
- kelnos 6y ago> I wished there was a service where a bigger / more intimidating person would knock on their door and ask them to cut it out, instead of small and fragile looking me That exists, and it's called the police. If your neighbor is violating noise ordinances, they'll get ticketed. If they're not, perhaps they're violating building rules, and can be fined by the building management. If still not, then you unfortunately just live in a shitty building, and hiring a thug to harass your neighbor (regardless of how loud they're being) sounds like a pretty disgusting (and legally risky) thing to do.
- bradj 6y agoThis already happens in some places. For example, in Houston, HOAs and other neighborhood management districts will contract with Constables to have a dedicated deputy in their neighborhood with a separate contact number. Others will contract with armed private security to patrol their neighborhoods as well. Also, this is how people use the police already. They call them when they are annoyed with their neighbors, the infamous woman in Central Park that was covered heavily in the news this year comes to mind.
- ffhhj 6y agoImagine thieves calling different private forces to confront "fake" security guards. Like that guy who asked construction workers from craiglist to meet with him next to the bank, but now with guns involved.
- jackson1442 6y ago> Like that guy who asked construction workers from craiglist to meet with him next to the bank This seems like an interesting story, got a link?
- ffhhj 6y agohttps://www.cnet.com/news/bank-robber-hires-decoys-on-craigslist-fools-cops/ https://www.cnet.com/news/bank-robber-hires-decoys-on-craigs...
- kelnos 6y ago> Imagine the poor family across the street, who gets visited by a black SUV and a group of burly looking suited security guards, likely telling them something vague about a "disturbance" that was reported. In some ways I would honestly love to get my door buzzed by these people so I could tell them to get off my property lest I call the actual police to remove them. (But such is my privilege that I would likely be pretty safe and unafraid in such an encounter.)