5 ms·
Vigilantism is scary stuff. I was on reddit and ran across a video that the submission claimed to be of someone poisoning local pets. The video showed someone
by duxup 6y ago
Vigilantism is scary stuff.
I was on reddit and ran across a video that the submission claimed to be of someone poisoning local pets. The video showed someone pouring something on the ground from a distance. We never see what it is.
Later we get a video where the camera person is screaming at the person they are recording. The person just walks away as the camera person follows them yelling.
I was a bit horrified that when I expressed in some skepticism I was meet with a lot of arguments like.
"Why didn't they stop to talk if they're innocent?"
"They didn't deny it."
"You know people really do this."
"You don't have to defend a dog killer you know."
People just took the text claims at face value despite the video showing nothing that it claimed, because they were upset by the claim in the text.
Apps that just have text and a photo, not even an image of a crime, people will believe it whole hog.
A during riots in Minneapolis a local social media apps and sites had rumors spread fast about drive by shootings by people on pickup trucks with assault rifles. These rumor spread several nights in a row despite it never appearing in the news and it being obvious that the previous night's rumors were 100% false.
One city council member spread the rumors of a full on Klan rally in a park with robes hoods and all... a completely absurd claim, folks bought it and spread it.
So back to the app, we have an app whose audience wants to hear this kind of information. That's a scary audience.
- agency 6y agoI mean this is the same forum that whipped itself into a frenzy trying to track down a random kid they collectively decided must have been behind the Boston marathon bombing.
- tolbish 6y agoHN loves to sneer at reddit, but reddit (and HN) is just a microcosm of humanity. If you want to see groupthink/mobs on here, enter any thread about the benefits or drawbacks of cryptocurrencies.
- duxup 6y agoEveryone deserves a good sneer now and then but I come to HN because people generally look closer / think about second order effects and so on. Reddit generally not at all.
- tolbish 6y agoThat's generally true of the large/default subreddits with no community guidelines.
- sangnoir 6y ago> Everyone deserves a good sneer now and then but I come to HN because people generally look closer / think about second order effects and so on. Wait until you encounter HN's incorrect hot-takes that get upvoted to top-comment in a niche field you have expertise or personal experience in - especially if it's in a non-tech field. I wouldn't bet on HNs superiority over Reddit, except for a very narrow band of fields. A comment doesn't have to be correct - it just needs to conform to audiences biases in a seemingly cogent way, right or wrong.
- generalizations 6y agoYeah, I've seen this before. Doesn't give me a lot of confidence in the collective wisdom of hn.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wearywanderer 6y agoThose poor hapless cryptocurrencies, wrongfully accused of murder. I implore my fellow HN participants to please consider the feelings of cryptocurrencies before engaging in vigilante justice against them. Seriously, maybe some of the criticism of cryptocurrencies here is over the top, but it is not even remotely comparable to what reddit has done.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- IgorPartola 6y agoDid I miss something? IIRC Boston police asked foe help finding the people who carried out the bombing and then found them with the help of the general public. The two individuals did carry out the attack, one is dead and one went to court. Was there more to this?
- ilikehurdles 6y agoYes, there was. Reddit went after the wrong person.
- shkkmo 6y agoReddit started a media driven frenzy over this missing person that further hurt an already tramatized family: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunil_Tripathi https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunil_Tripathi As far as I am aware, crowd sourcing via social media did not assist with indentifying and catching the suspects.
- strathmeyer 6y agoOh, how did Reddit do that? Or are you all just full of shit? Do you think there are people who don't use both sites?
- shkkmo 6y agoFeel free to do your own research as the whole process by which this misinformation was created and then spread is pretty well documented. There are quite a few sites and journalists that bear responsibility, but reddit is where it all started. Your tone is not appropriate to HN.
- resoluteteeth 6y agoYes. https://www.businessinsider.com/reddit-falsely-accuses-sunil-tripathi-of-boston-bombing-2013-7 https://www.businessinsider.com/reddit-falsely-accuses-sunil...
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- wnevets 6y ago> People just took the text claims at face value despite the video showing nothing that it claimed, because they were upset by the claim in the text. It seems like a lot of content on reddit is like this.
- duxup 6y agoYeah there's a large volume of sort of 'choose your own adventure / cause and add your own title to this video / pic' content.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]