4 ms·
> a tinge of anti-government sort of sentiment. It might have overtones, but this is the decentralized versus centralized control (peer-peer vs client/server)
by hinkley 6y ago
> a tinge of anti-government sort of sentiment.
It might have overtones, but this is the decentralized versus centralized control (peer-peer vs client/server) merry-go-round that we are all stuck on.
There are practical reasons why you don't want a central authority: because other central authorities can destroy it. But with no central authority what do you do when someone tries to make themselves... for lack of a better term, a central pain in the ass?
Peer systems fail when someone can make everything about themselves with far less effort than it takes for a simple majority to stop them. It's asymmetric warfare if I can be naughty for 5 hours and 100 people have to spend an equal amount of time to undo whatever I've done.
The central authority can often do this much cheaper, especially if there is a collaborative health system (eg, report user). But they also paint a target on themselves in the process.
- endisneigh 6y agothanks for the reply I'd argue that pretty much every civilization has tried the peer-to-peer thing in the beginning. I won't get too much into the history of bartering, but to your point regarding a central pain in the ass, I think that's why the entire world has sort of settled on "proof of violence." ultimately, like you've said, the only way to defend your position when you're a large central authority is with violence.
- delaaxe 6y agoThere isn't much evidence that bartering ever was the way people did business. Lots of evidence for lending & borrowing though (debt).
- endisneigh 6y agoindeed - bartering really isn't a sustainable thing, and like you mentioned debt ended up being heavily used to facilitate exchanges. said debt in many cases ended up being centrally facilitated. the rest of history.