3 ms·
Key takeaways - asymmetric broadband (high download speeds, low upload speeds) won't work in a world where people are doing real work "in a world of Zoom confe
by cratermoon 6y ago
Key takeaways
- asymmetric broadband (high download speeds, low upload speeds) won't work in a world where people are doing real work "in a world of Zoom conferences, we need something that is more symmetric in download and upload — or at least upload speeds need to be a lot faster than they were when it was mostly Netflix and HBO Max"
- rural/urban divide is real and a severe problem "for the most part, cities have done reasonably well, and rural areas have done reasonably badly. So this divide is really economic and population density"
- the free market has few, if any, incentives, to build out to rural and low-density areas "If you are running a wire, whether it be cable or fiber, it costs the same amount per mile pretty much no matter where you put it. So if you can put it someplace where you can service 100,000 people, it’s a lot more economically advantageous than if you’re going to be serving 20"
- there isn't any real free market anyway, since most locales have a single provider, maybe two "while there may be multiple internet providers, there are very few internet providers at any single place. So we essentially have, at least in regions, de facto monopolies that have very little reason to increase their offerings, at least from the sense of competition.
- jobs will not be completely unconnected to location "It’s still going to matter that you are in the same area so that on occasion, you can come into the office and meet physically together. But I think there’s going to be much less of the five days a week on campus sort of work. People will be able to work two to three days a week at home, without any loss of productivity or loss of culture within their group."
- Dah00n 6y agoI'm constantly baffled at how the US can be stuck in this situation, being a country known for high tech businesses like Google etc. Especially when well-tested and proven solutions are readily available if politicians were interested. For example the problem with only one ISP is easy to fix (in theory, I know it isn't politically): Force infrastructure providers to open up for competitors. All electricity companies can be picked as a provider on the local infrastructure where I live and the same with internet. Even very rural areas have fibre (though there's nothing as rual as rual America of course). In my opinion all these problems stem from the two party system where nothing really changes so everything becomes inefficient in the long run.
- dudul 5y agoI'm probably kind of ignorant here, but isn't there a difference between ISP and electricity providers though? When it comes to electricity, the infrastructure is used to bring the product (electricity) to the customer. When it comes to Internet, the infrastructure is the product. Say the infrastructure is now open for all companies. What is now the differentiator between Comcast and Fios? The infrastructure and the bandwidth it can handle is what they are selling.
- cratermoon 5y agoHow is the infrastructure the product? If I buy a cable modem and plug it into the wall but don't cough up money to Comcast/XFinity, I get nothing, same as if I plug my coffee pot into an electrical outlet but don't pay the electric company for service.
- dudul 5y agoElectric cables can be shared by different companies because they still have the differentiator of how they get the electricity they sell you. Either they make it, or buy it and negotiate prices, etc. The electricity is the product, not how they get it to your house. What would be a differentiator for ISPs if the infrastructure was completely shared? The internet would be the same.
- cratermoon 5y agooh, you have NO IDEA. How about: not hijacking your DNS to redirect domains? not using traffic shaping to favor content the ISP makes money from over other content? Not blocking torrent ports? Not having monthly usage caps? Not filtering or blocking content based on country of origin? Not blocking Tor? Not requiring you to rent the router/modem from the ISP and have them control it? In other words, all those Net Neutrality things that the FCC took away. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_neutrality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Net_neutrality
- 5y ago