2 ms·
Animals speak with scent, posture, gesture, and other means as well as with sound; and focusing solely on the audible portions of animal communication is never
by h2odragon 5y ago
Animals speak with scent, posture, gesture, and other means as well as with sound; and focusing solely on the audible portions of animal communication is never going to work well.
Raising my blind baby goat (as part of a dog pack), is showing me this anew: the dogs are having trouble talking to the baby because she can't see the postures and gestures. Scent and sound and feel are fine, but growly dogs' "respect my space and play nice" isn't being communicated at all.
- dopidopHN 5y agoThey address some of it on their documentation. It’s seems that various version of sign language will be their first target of non audio communication.
- spython 5y agoExactly, it seems to me that animals communicate within the context of the current situation (e.g. a dog would combining a specific bark, body orientation, neck fur standing up, to signify "there is something in this direction and I don't like it"). Decoding any one part of the expression wouldn't make us able to understand the whole meaning. This is also what makes two-way communication so hard – we are so focused on our language that we often fail to develop or account for our other ways of expression, (and if we do rediscover our non-verbal expressiveness, it often come in a way of a hacky and very verbal ted-talk or book). So for two-way communication our animal counterparts first have to learn our repressed, underdeveloped body language, gesture, posture and facial expressions.