4 ms·
Not trying to badmouth the university here, but having to trust the statement of those who broke your trust in the first place doesn't meet my definition of "kn
by atoav 5y ago
Not trying to badmouth the university here, but having to trust the statement of those who broke your trust in the first place doesn't meet my definition of "knowing" something.
Maybe "believe" would be better used here? Knowing would mean to know precisely what each of these changes does and whether they open up new vulnerabilities and then having confidence that all is well. Gaining this confidence requires work. And unless you put that work in, you are left to trusting/believing.
(Edit: what I mean here is that the researchers could be totally nice and ethical people, but the Linux devs would still have to either take a risk by trusting them OR put in the work to check it all OR decide not to put in that work)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- addingnumbers 5y ago80 developers reviewing for a month isn't enough work for you? They just put more man-hours into reviewing these commits than the contributors put into writing them.
- fartcannon 5y agoIt'll be interesting to see their next paper, where they describe in great depth how to waste 80 developers time for a month and still sneak in vulnerabilities.
- high_density 5y agoif 80 devs all read the same part same way, it won't make much of a difference. maybe the issue is we aren't using static analysis enough / don't have enough static analysis tools?
- neatze 5y ago> researchers could be totally nice and ethical people. A thorough review of the IRB documents revealed potential problems in the description of the experiments, and concluded that insufficient details about the experimental study were provided to the IRB. [0] [0]Read the above linked IEEE response latter.
- ikerdanzel 5y agoWhat the uni guys did was correct. The Linux devs only able to review their codes because they are alerted. I am very sure there are plenty of bad faith commits that were accepted by Linux devs. For one, any governments with interest for backdoors with resources beyond the combine all Linux devs would have done it. Instead of appreciating what the uni did, they go beserk because their ego bruised. I am not surprised if within the next 5 years we going to hear more about this issue just that this time the parties involved are not that university.