2 ms·
For the same reason you trust an auditor and accountant hired by Tesla to produce quartely earnings report - they are on the hook if they lie. Surely you do no
by ClumsyPilot 5y ago
For the same reason you trust an auditor and accountant hired by Tesla to produce quartely earnings report - they are on the hook if they lie.
Surely you do not hire an independant accountant every time you buy stocks?
- AbrahamParangi 5y agoAn auditor hired by the seller has an incentive to make the seller happy that you cannot eliminate, only reduce through legal threats. An auditor hired by the buyer has no such incentive.
- teddyh 5y agoYou’re thinking of the monetary incentive only, which might be too narrow a view. The “regulatory capture” principle might apply here – an auditor only meets any one client once in their life, but probably meets some landlords many times, presumably develops a relationship with them, and might want to tend to not upset that relationship.
- InitialLastName 5y ago>Surely you do not hire an independant accountant every time you buy stocks? Of course not, I let the short sellers do it for me.
- Judgmentality 5y agoThen you'd miss out on GME, TSLA, and all the stocks that make the most money. That's obviously a viable strategy, but it's certainly not the best in terms of ROI.
- edmundsauto 5y agoYou also probably miss out on the fraud and negative ROI that the investigations would conceivably uncover. Also, making decisions around catching Tesla or GME at the right timing in the market… that’s not a great starting point for investment strategy.
- Judgmentality 5y ago> Also, making decisions around catching Tesla or GME at the right timing in the market… that’s not a great starting point for investment strategy. I thought the same thing for years, and just avoided the market except for a 401k and stock granted by companies I worked at. Then I got into trading because I thought I could make money trading volatile stocks and I've never looked back (I've already made enough to retire). So far I've only lost money on my value stocks. To each his own.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoDo you work on your own accord then and do not need to subject yourself to a boss?
- Judgmentality 5y agoYep, I quit my job in tech and just do whatever I want currently. I may take another regular job, I may not. I'd hardly even call what I do now "work," although I am still actively investing.
- shard 5y agoDo you think your case is a typical case? How much does experience count? How much did you need to educate yourself to reach this level? Were there any major stumbles or obstacles? I am encouraged by your story, but am also weary that it only sounds reasonable because all the harrowing details were left out.
- Judgmentality 5y agoI think I got lucky, but I think luck is required to be successful at anything (including coding). I actually haven't had any bad luck yet, the only stocks I've lost money on so far have been some of my value stocks. I fully expect some of my risky investments to go south. The best advice I can give is pretty generic - follow the data. First of all actually find the data. Don't trust some finance news rag to tell you anything meaningful, some of them actually have a direct incentive to lie to you. Now that you have the data, what does it say? This sounds simple, but everyone told me I was an idiot to invest in GME in January. They said the same thing in March. So far my investment in GME has more than a 10x ROI. I'm just using GME as an example because it's topical - people tell me I'm in a cult while I'm actively making money betting against them. "Buy the rumor, sell the news" is pretty easy to understand, just find a stock you know well (I would guess something in tech, like Alphabet or Amazon but whatever) and look at dates for stock movements, rumors, and announcements. You can do this retroactively to find a pattern then try to apply it moving forward. "Never invest in something you don't understand" is general advice outside of stocks, but just an extension of what I said initially - do your own research until it makes sense to you. I think a huge amount of inertia is just people afraid to try it because they've been conditioned their entire lives to believe they can't make money doing it. I'm quickly realizing how much of this is bullshit (I realize I'm lucky and I understand I'm likely in a local maxima, but I am still extremely confident a lot of the things I've been told are just wrong). So take a small amount of money and invest it and see how it goes. Learn. Iterate. Improve. The goal is to start making money before you lose it. I actually started with just $10k and once I started to figure it out put in more money as I wanted to increase my profit. At the end of the day it's your money and you should do what you want with it. So long as you understand you will definitely lose money sometimes and are willing to learn from it, give it a go with whatever money you're willing to lose.
- lotsofpulp 5y ago> For the same reason you trust an auditor and accountant hired by Tesla to produce quartely earnings report - they are on the hook if they lie. “On the hook” has different meanings when you have the enforcement power of the US federal government and criminal courts versus an individual who has to cough up tens of thousands for lawyers in civil court.
- Kirby64 5y agoLie vs. miss is relative. Every single inspector in the US at least has liability that only extends to the cost of their inspection (or, sometimes, 2x their inspection cost...). Hardly enough to cover any losses if there is major damage that is overlooked. I had a friend who bought a house with major termite damage (i.e., every wall had to be removed to repair the studs basically), and 2 inspectors overlooked the damage. He said in retrospect (after doing a bunch of research on termite damage), it should have been obvious to inspectors, but they missed it. He tried to pursue legal action against either the seller or the inspectors, and basically was told: impossible to prove seller knew (as there was no repairs done), and inspectors are not held liable.
- lfowles 5y agoHah yes, inspectors try to be as minimally liable as possible. Ours went to great lengths to get us to have someone come out and check the "stains" underneath a bathroom sink without actually saying the m-word that rhymes with cold :)
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoHome inspectors in the US are barely useful. If you really don't know anything about houses (or feel as if you do not), then having someone walk you through some of the things you may have to face living in a particular house is probably a good idea. However, even as just an enthusiastic amateur, I know more about home construction and repair than most home inspectors. When I bought my current house I skipped the home inspector, and hired an electrician, a roofer and a structural engineer. It cost me more, but I got seriously informed reports about the property, not just boilerplate fill-in-the-blank PDFs telling me that one of the windows rattled.
- shard 5y agoI like your solution of gathering subject matter experts and getting individual reports. Did the 3 of them cover all aspects of the house? I am not an expert so I don't know if anything is left out, does the structural engineer also cover plumbing? Or is that not an issue?
- jonfw 5y agoIf I was going to drop the kind of money that I did on my house on retail stocks, then you can bet that I'd be doing some due diligence on my end that's worth at least the same few hundred bucks