5 ms·
So it's legal to discriminate people living in certain neighborhoods?
by croes 6y ago
So it's legal to discriminate people living in certain neighborhoods?
- kspacewalk2 6y agoWhy not? Neighbourhood is not a protected status like race, gender, national origin, age, disability, etc.
- tguedes 6y agoExcept in America our neighborhoods are heavily influenced by race so I doubt you could legally ban against hiring from a neighborhood made up 90%+ African Americans.
- swashboon 6y agoWell, you wouldn't be sued because you banned hiring from the neighborhood. You would be sued for discriminating against a protected class under a paper thin veil of banning a location.
- bombcar 6y agoRequiring that employees live at within X minutes of the job site - likely legal. Forbidding employees from certain locations as a proxy for a protected class - likely illegal. An example: during the sales tax wars many companies would refuse to hire from a state that would could the employee as a tax nexus. This is mostly gone now as the sales tax fight seems mostly over.
- lostcolony 6y agoIs it? Even outside of sales tax, it's additional accounting overhead to handle the withholding and filing for states you aren't in. No idea how much, I would imagine it's dependent on the systems in use, but the organizational incentives for allowing and enabling it are probably horribly misaligned for many companies.
- bombcar 6y agoIt's a hassle but not an huge one, and any company that is in a population center that straddles a state border already deals with this (think New York, Chicago, Portland, Minneapolis/St Paul) - once you can handle two states handling additional isn't that painful. More importantly the COST associated is fixed per employee roughly - having an employee in another state doesn't usually change the amount of tax paid, etc - just who it's paid to. This won't be entirely true, but it's close enough - and for companies with outsourced HR (think: ADP) it's even easier. Any company big enough to have a significant number of employees that this applies to would be big enough to eat the cost (and probably already has offices/etc in multiple states as is).
- vageli 6y agoIt seems in some cases, yes. For instance many police and fire departments require you to live within X miles of the station. It also wouldn't seem odd if a company decided to exclude remote workers from places in which the company does not have a nexus, to avoid further complicating taxes.
- KMag 6y agoPresumably that's legal, as long as there isn't a clear correlation between excluded neighborhoods and protected classes. I'm not a lawyer. This is not legal advice.
- lmkg 6y agoThe thing you're looking for is the legal doctrine of "Disparate Impact." Discrimination against a protected class (like race) is illegal. Geography is not a protected class, and discrimination based on geography is not inherently illegal. But under the doctrine of Disparate Impact, a particular policy of geographic exclusion is illegal if it happens to have outsized effect on a protected class (and has no business justification). Note that Disparate Impact does not require intention!