6 ms·
I don't see why Oregon would object unless there is some industry out there that is paying megabucks in taxes. Dumping a bunch of people sucking down more mone
by bsder 5y ago
I don't see why Oregon would object unless there is some industry out there that is paying megabucks in taxes.
Dumping a bunch of people sucking down more money than they pay seems like a win for Oregon.
Idaho, on the other hand, might object. That would be comedy gold.
"We secede." "Congratulations! Good luck finding somebody who wants you, though."
- omni 5y agoWell for one, House representatives are apportioned based on population.
- Ericson2314 5y agoThat's fine, it doesn't matter what state the representative is associated with, and baring rounding errors the number of representatives would stay roughly the same? The more worrisome effect is on the electoral college and the senate, but I think tying this to DC statehood would get rid of that.
- Thrymr 5y ago> it doesn't matter what state the representative is associated with, and baring rounding errors the number of representatives would stay roughly the same? The [Republican] Idaho legislature would get to gerrymand the districts instead of the [Democratic] Oregon legislature.
- Ericson2314 5y agoFair point I didn't think that far. But now as I do, per https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idaho%27s_congressional_districts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idaho%27s_congressional_distri... they are all Republican by wide margin already, so there's no real gerrymandering to do.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- KeytarHero 5y agoIs there enough population in these counties to make any difference?
- icedistilled 5y agoIt sets a bad precedent. Any county can just vote to break off into another state due to political reasons or to form their own state? Either one party will use that to their advantage and disallow the other party from doing the same, or every state will devolve into fragments. Why stop at counties? Why can't zip codes choose the grouping that best represents them too?
- nickff 5y agoI fail to see how this would be a 'bad precedent' or 'problem'. Why is keeping arbitrary borders established over a hundred years ago more important than better representation and sortition?
- lainga 5y agoThe balance of seats in the Senate
- nickff 5y ago>" The balance of seats in the Senate " Do you mean the House? I think the Senate would still have 2 senators per state, and state-level electoral results are unlikely to change if an alienated minority from one state secedes, in favor of joining a more (politically) similar state.
- rootusrootus 5y agoWhat happens when you get down to the last county and they also want to join another state?
- nickff 5y agoIf there were a one-county state, it would benefit from so much graft that they'd never join anyone else. Imagine having two senators, one congressman, and three electoral votes, all in one county! Every presidential candidate would stop there and promise them the moon!