4 ms·
Ooof, now the (still somewhat) open macOS is thrown under the bus by Apple just to make iOS look good. FWIW, I never had malware problems, neither on Windows,
by flohofwoe 5y ago
Ooof, now the (still somewhat) open macOS is thrown under the bus by Apple just to make iOS look good.
FWIW, I never had malware problems, neither on Windows, macOS/OSX nor Linux. I caught a harmless virus on Windows in 1998 or so, but that was it. Of course I'm not a "casual user", but I also didn't take any preventive actions except installing a browser adblocker (which really should be common sense by now).
- headmelted 5y agoYou never had malware problems that you know of.
- luxuryballs 5y ago- the brain immediately as you turn in for the night
- flohofwoe 5y agoTrue :D But my machines were never rendered unusable, and of course I'm keeping the usual security mechanisms switched on (Windows SmartScreen, UAC and Defender). I'm also not keeping anything really important on my computers though, the simple rule is "if this computer stops working now, I won't loose anything of value") - because this has actually happened a few times to me over the years, but always because of failing hardware.
- aequitas 5y agoSo the login credentials for your email (and thereby the possibility to reset all your account's passwords) are not stored on your computer (on disk or memory)? The least useful thing for malware to do is to render your computer unusable. As that would prompt you to reinstall it or investigate the cause.
- DavideNL 5y agoPerhaps it's a subtle nudge towards "okay we're making macOS just as locked down as iOS from now on... welcome to our new walled garden."
- headmelted 5y agoI quite like were macOS is on this topic philosophically with XProtect and Gatekeeper. I don't think Craig is being necessarily fair to macOS in his framing, as they've gone much further than Windows has and Linux realistically can, but I get that he's trying to win the debate in the eyes of the court. It's a great (if not perfect) way to provide some protection over software from outside the App Store, but he's right in suggesting that it just wouldn't scale to the sheer amount of mobile software people would install on iOS because a shady ad banner told them to. (Basing this on Linux being free and as a result not coming with a monitoring team for notarisation of software in the wild).
- 3GuardLineups 5y agoplease god no. Imagine having to download everything through the app store. Infantilizing fucks
- snowwrestler 5y agoPeople have been trying to read these tea leaves for almost 15 years now and it still hasn’t happened. MacOS and iOS are complementary and expand Apple’s market by addressing different segments. If MacOS worked exactly like iOS, Apple would lose computer customers to Windows or Linux. Also, a reminder that Apple actually ships 5 different operating systems to deliver their segmentation strategy: MacOS, iOS, iPadOS, tvOS, watchOS.
- mcphage 5y agoGatekeeper has gotten much more aggressive than when it first released. So maybe they're stopping where they are, but I don't think that's the only possibility.
- threatofrain 5y agoIt needs to happen if the health app comes to MacOS.
- zaphar 5y agoYou are the equivalent of a race car driver in the car analogy he made though. You are not the teenager just learning to drive. His statement that IOS is safe for a child to use is largely correct. macOS can not make the same claim. He isn't throwing it under the bus so much as identifying that they are different platforms with different use cases and arguing that just because macOS doesn't have the same restrictions is an apples and orange comparison.
- oauea 5y agoSure and if we coddle everyone then there will be no more "race car drivers" in the next generation, because they won't have had the opportunity to use their no-longer-general computers.
- zaphar 5y agoApple coddling it's users is not coddling everyone. You still have Android, Pinephone, Linux laptops, Virtual Machines, and a whole host of other enthusiast platforms. Even though the vast majority of cars have a plethora of safety features there is is still a thriving amateur racing scene that isn't going away and is a path for those who want to be race car drivers. Meanwhile I get a car that I can turn on cruise control in traffic and not have to think as hard about speed and as a result get a much safer and more enjoyable experience on long car trips.
- swiley 5y agoThe affect is the same, it's most apparent in chat apps. Because of Apple's abuse of its ownership of people's phones there are no popular decentralized chat apps. It's not feasible to maintain a chat app for iOS by volunteers because the app authors must also maintain infrastructure for push notifications (Apple does not allow this to be delegated to, for example, the chat server operators who already have volunteers that can handle this.)
- ashneo76 5y agoApple coddling is taken like word from god. The IT them at my work threatened about disabling SIP. Apple can go fuck itself with that crap. I have sudo, I alike be able to shoot myself in the foot. And I have and that made me a better engineer today. I should be able to disable that
- GeekyBear 5y ago> Ooof, now the (still somewhat) open macOS is thrown under the bus by Apple just to make iOS look good. Trojan horses for Macs are a thing. Just as they are a thing for every other OS that allows users to install anything from anywhere. Malware scanners can never catch all the new variants, but as they are identified, updates to the malware scanner can remove them. Is it throwing Android under the bus to note that you are much more likely to install a trojan horse when you sideload apps?