3 ms·
Well, the industrial revolution with its child labour, or colonisation with outright slavery "got us to where we are" in many ways, but then we decided that was
by arp242 5y ago
Well, the industrial revolution with its child labour, or colonisation with outright slavery "got us to where we are" in many ways, but then we decided that wasn't such a great idea after all. And hey, fossil fuels got us very far too. But maybe we should stop with that too and move beyond them.
I don't even agree with the author, or not exactly anyway, but I don't think this type of "it's the system that got us here"-type of reasoning is a good argument at all.
- andrew_ 5y agoDon't be so obtuse. we aren't talking about individual aspects, the author clearly suggests a fundamental change of the entire system. flawed child labor laws, or a lack of thereof, do not define capitalism.
- arp242 5y agoEntire economies were built on slavery. This isn't a little trivial aspect.
- andrew_ 5y agoslavery also is not a tenet of capitalism. slavery is a separate societal issue that permeates every economic system. you are conflating societal issues with economic systems.
- arp242 5y agoThere is no such thing as "capitalism", it's a vague ideology with myriad different implementations. Besides, that wasn't even my point, you've turned this in to a the Not True Capitalism™ word-game, my point was merely that many systems that "got us to where we are" have since been abandoned, and that merely "it's useful" is not a good argument.
- andrew_ 5y agowhen it comes to word-games, you're putting on one heck of a display. Capitalism isn't a vague ideology - it's literally defined as: an economic and political system in which a country's trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit, rather than by the state. You seem intent on conflating historical societal issues that have come and gone under a capitalist economic system. I'd argue we are where we are despite those societal issues, and that capitalism has endured through them.