4 ms·
Open Source is socialism stuck in a capitalist world. A square peg trying to fit a round hole. This should have been obvious from the start. Good luck changing
by jqpabc123 6y ago
Open Source is socialism stuck in a capitalist world. A square peg trying to fit a round hole.
This should have been obvious from the start. Good luck changing the world to fit.
- throwaway316943 6y agoI think it has more anarchist influence than socialist.
- jqpabc123 6y agoSame response as above. You don't need licenses with dozens of pages of legalese to prescribe "anarchy".
- throwaway316943 6y agoAnarchy doesn’t preclude the use of contracts.
- jqpabc123 6y agoA contract is meaningless without some entity (government) to enforce it.
- throwaway316943 6y agoOur current method of enforcement is government but any unbiased third party can be used. It could even be automated to avoid human failings. When you buy a house who holds the money while the property exchange is made?
- jqpabc123 6y ago... any unbiased third party can be used. Under who's authority? If government didn't exist, one of the first things people would do is recreate it. And your comments reflect this.
- throwaway316943 5y agoThe important difference is having a choice of who you deal with.
- dgellow 6y agoNothing to do with socialism or capitalism. FLOSS has always been about users freedom.
- jqpabc123 6y agoFreedom is called "public domain". You don't need hundreds of legal licenses to enforce "freedom". You only need these if you aim to restrict and channel freedom in an effort to promote a social agenda.
- hirundo 6y ago> Open Source is socialism stuck in a capitalist world. Then so are families, churches and other voluntary associations. But I don't think they are. I think it becomes socialism when it becomes a form of government, enforced with law. Cooperative, non-profit associations may not be capitalism, but they are compatible with it. Capitalists may try to tempt members of such into rent paying relationships, but as this week's Freenode episode demonstrates, their powers in that direction are distinctly limited. We're living through huge growth in both proprietary and open software. To me these trends seem to reinforce, not oppose each other. I think that capitalism is a somewhat less jealous god than socialism, in that it more easily coexists and cooperates with other forms.
- jqpabc123 6y agoI think it becomes socialism when it becomes a form of government, enforced with law. The objective of the GPL is to use the law (i.e. government) to enforce a system of socialism.
- hirundo 6y agoIn this case those laws are enforcing capitalist-style property rights, which are not limited to profit-seeking associations. The creators, or their assignees, own the enforced rights, and among their property rights is the power to distribute those rights as they see fit. Socialist property rights are more likely to be assigned to the community, with less regard for the rights of the creators. A socialist OSS society may still have a GPL, but choosing that license would be less the right of the developers and more the right of political representatives.
- Zezov 6y agoThe thing I like the most about capitalism is the whole laissez-faire liberalism aspect. You do what you think best, I do what I think best. I don't have to do things your way, you don't have to do things my way. In particular, this is what allows us to try out new things: for one, open source. It's really nice to not need approval from anyone before starting your new project, and to me that's the best part of capitalism (though you may choose to call that liberalism instead, it's the same laissez-faire spirit: each person does what they think is best.) A capitalist world is therefore a great place for open source to grow and blossom—rightly or wrong, you might not like capitalism for other reasons, but this, at least, is to its credit. (I myself would also argue with describing Open Source as socialism, for similar reasons—the laissez-faire spirit of everyone doing what they think is best is the spirit of capitalism as I see it. But that's mostly just a semantic point.)
- jqpabc123 6y agoA capitalist word is therefore a great place for open source to grow and blossom... Alrighty then. So Open Source is growing and blossoming in capitalism and there is no problem and this article is just totally misguided?
- Zezov 6y agoYes, open source is doing quite well. Nothing is perfect. There are things worth improving. But it's hard to look at all the amazing open source projects that exist and not be impressed. Is there more to be done? Sure. But don't take for granted what we have. Nor should we throw away what we have because it's imperfect. So no, I'm not saying that everything is perfect as it is. I do think the article is misguided in its focus, though. The way I'd frame it is something like this: What we have is great, but not perfect. So let's work to make it even better.