4 ms·
> does anyone really think that the FSF would be able to stand up in a copyright court against Apple and Google? I do. I strongly suspect I’m not the only one.
by sokoloff 6y ago
> does anyone really think that the FSF would be able to stand up in a copyright court against Apple and Google?
I do. I strongly suspect I’m not the only one.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ChrisLomont 6y agoFSF annual budget is on order of 1.3M [1], a tiny portion of which can be spent on legal fees, the rest being normal operations - people and hardware and offices and such. So, if lucky, FSF can afford $200k / year in a court battle. Google v Oracle racked up around $2M a year for google in legal fees alone (at least early on - I didn't find a final cost for the decade of litigation) [2]. And either could afford vastly more as needed, especially if it could simply bankrupt their opponent and get a default win. I don't think the FSF can even remotely cover such costs. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_Software_Foundation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_Software_Foundation [2] https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-wants-4-million-from-oracle-for-legal-costs/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-wants-4-million-from-or...
- sokoloff 6y agoI think it’s a mistake to look at the FSF peacetime budget and conclude they couldn’t sustain a war. If Apple or Google were foolish enough to allow themselves to be pitted head-to-head with the FSF on a clear AGPL violation (the premise of TFA), FSF would easily raise the money required (in dollars and in pro-bono work). I’m not even especially a fan of AGPL and I’d crack my wallet open pretty wide for the FSF side here.
- karatinversion 6y agoAnd the fact that Apple refuses to use any GPLv3 software suggests that Apple's lawyers think so, too.
- giomasce 6y agoSame with Google and AGPL. Also, court cases are not just decided by the amount of money you pour in them. You need money to prepare correctly the case and work a good strategy, but in the end facts are considered, and if someone violates copyright, they're going to be found guilty, be them a small company or a FAANG.
- ghaff 6y agoIn both those cases, it's also just about risk/benefit. There's relatively little software that uses those licenses, which are (relatively) new as licenses go and AFAIK there is no legal precedent around them. So I daresay companies just figure there's not a lot of advantage to offering some AGPL service in particular and there is a risk of exposing their proprietary back-end to a lawsuit.