I disagree. The first comment generalizes the members of a religious/ethnic group and is hateful. The second is an (incorrect, IMO) idea that is commonly believ

I disagree. The first comment generalizes the members of a religious/ethnic group and is hateful. The second is an (incorrect, IMO) idea that is commonly believed by supporters of a political movement that has sought take ownership over Judaism. There is very little discussion to be had about the first, but there is room to debate the second. But maybe this is a reflection of my own biases - the first statement offends me personally and makes me want to walk away from the conversation while the second just sounds wrong and makes me want to engage.