3 ms·
£300 for a train ticket and you are happy? Have you been on a train in China, France or even Czech Republic? This parody for 'competition' has given us most ex
by ClumsyPilot 5y ago
£300 for a train ticket and you are happy? Have you been on a train in China, France or even Czech Republic?
This parody for 'competition' has given us most expensive fares in Europe and soviet-block quality of rail service.
It's a new disease, 'neoliberalism of the brain' that maintains 'free market' even at the cost of organ failure
- iso1631 5y agohttps://www.seat61.com/uk-europe-train-fares-comparison.html https://www.seat61.com/uk-europe-train-fares-comparison.html > the next time someone says (or you read) "Britain has the highest rail fares in Europe", you'll know this is only 15% of the story. The other 85% is that we have similar or even cheaper fares, too. The big picture is that Britain has the most commercially aggressive fares in Europe, with the highest fares designed to get maximum revenue from business travel, and some of the lowest fares designed to get more revenue by filling more seats.
- morrbo 5y agoI'm sorry but this article is bullshit. Go and actually check the train prices (because I did) now. Book Sheffield to London 1 month in advance, comes out to £70 odd return (nearly 4x more than article states) with a first class upgrade for an extra £70....Paris to Leon 1 month in advance? £20 odd return with another £20 first class. Idk if something has changed but you can't quote this article anymore. Train prices in the UK are criminal.
- smcl 5y agoSeconded, this article is quite misleading. The UK fares always seemed quite unpredictable to me when I used them, with variances similar to those you see when booking flight tickets. Maybe the fares have an extra component based on demand? If I look for second-class tickets from Edinburgh to Montrose (which I went on semi-regularly) @ scotrail.co.uk on 1st June I see prices that fluctuate from £9.30 to £24.60. Maybe the guy only looked at the lower-bound on the London-Sheffield route?
- iso1631 5y agoYes, train fares are based on demand, same as plane and coach fares. Same as they are in Europe (The Paris-Dijon journey in a months time is between €31 and €71 depending on what time you choose) For walk up fares, Edinburgh to Montrose is 100 miles each way, an "off peak" return (so any time after 0930) is £34 if you limit yourself to LNER trains or 17p/mile, or £41 return for a choice of LNER or Scotrail trains. If you want to travel before 0930 on whatever train turns up next, it's £48.60 or 24p/mile. What price do you think you should be paying? In 2019 Scotrail carried 1.8 billion passenger miles got £482.8m subsidy - a 27p per mile subsidy. The company made a £11m loss too. How much should the tax payer subsidise your Edinburgh-Montrose journey? 35p/mile/ 45p/mile?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- iso1631 5y agoThe article actually explains this, with different options > For travel today, bought at the station, immediate departure, outside the peaks... And > If travelling today in the business peak hours... It acknowledges that finance bros travelling from Manchester to London for a 9AM meeting and traveling back on the 1630 will pay more. That doesn't affect most people The summary makes it quite clear. The big picture is that Britain has the most commercially aggressive fares in Europe, with the highest fares designed to get maximum revenue from business travel, and some of the lowest fares designed to get more revenue by filling more seats. Basically a tax on last minute business travelers to subsidise leisure travelers and commuters.
- smcl 5y agoYeah I’d known about peak/off-peak, but it always seemed odd that there was such a wide range and that there were so many differently priced tickets within that range and I never knew the formula. An even longer journey I take here (Brno-Prague) seems to always be either 205kč or 245kč (£7-8.50). I know British rail travel is more expensive, it’s the (to me) unpredictable ticket pricing that I would like to decrypt
- iso1631 5y agohttps://i.imgur.com/bvviAcJ.png https://i.imgur.com/bvviAcJ.png £17.60 on the 12:05 departure on Jun 16th on trainsplit with one change - 10p/mile. And on the well-advertised and more expensive trainline on Jun 17th https://imgur.com/ymtzPhw.png https://imgur.com/ymtzPhw.png £31.50 on the 12:37 direct. £43.50 first class . The 11:22 SNCF Paris-Dijon on the same date is €31, or £27. The 12:22 is €40 (£35). One way. https://i.imgur.com/1Zs0APR.png https://i.imgur.com/1Zs0APR.png
- jokethrowaway 5y agoEverything is more expensive in the UK - salaries are higher too, compared to Europe.
- iso1631 5y agoTrain fares aren't (although the tax payer in France pays far more for train services -- services which are pretty rubbish compared with the UK. Compare somewhere like Lesparre (population about 5,000 and 40 miles from Beudeux), which has about 10 trains a day taking 90 minutes. With Cononley (25 miles out of Leeds) with 4 trains in each direction the next hour.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoLondon might be a beacon, but UK has the poorest regions in Western Europe. In fact some ex-soviet countries do better https://highpaycentre.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/High_Pay_Centre_briefing_pdf.pdf https://highpaycentre.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/High_Pa...
- Camas 5y agoPrices are "criminal" but not worth you doing more than a cursory search for a cheaper ticket?
- disabled 5y agoAusterity literally kills, and often leads to neoliberalism. “The Body Economic: Why Austerity Kills” by David Stuckler MPH PhD and Sanjay Basu MD PhD is an excellent read on the subject. The British, in no exaggeration, get taxed to death. You get horrible value for your tax dollar. I am saying this as an American who lives in Croatia, who pays quite a bit in taxes. However, I prefer to pay Croatian taxes (in addition to my US taxes) as a dual US|EU (Croatian) citizen, just for a stable, relaxed society. There is a very high baseline level of stress and anxiety living in America. It’s not worth living there again. Seriously, Croatians have a great lifestyle, with perhaps the best lifestyle in all of Europe. Also, if you die of coronavirus in America, it is nothing more than a statistic to both the government and the American population, which is not only unbelievably disgusting, but downright sadistic.
- dadelion 5y agoI couldn't be more surprised by this comment as someone born and raised in Croatia. You are the first person I heard who likes paying Croatian taxes. Do you follow the national news? There's always a steady stream of corruption news, especially recently. It's ironic you post this in a thread about rail. Croatia has a truly horrible rail system. It's universally mocked as useless. Regarding COVID, I would have agreed with you that Croatia did great last year in March, but from late summer 2020, it's been catastrophic. And Croatia depends on tourism, so there's a big incentive to get things to normal levels so tourists come. We could have been better than Portugal now. Also re COVID, have you witnessed the vaccination campaign? Have you seen how many politicians and their friends got vaccinated ahead of the elderly, despite guidelines saying vaccines should be given according to age? The rector of Zagreb university got a vaccine before my grandma. How is that not sadistic? Croatia has some great pros, such as a relaxed lifestyle, but you're really stretching it with calling it a rolemodel society and good value for taxes
- disabled 5y agoNobody likes paying taxes. I see it as my civic duty and absolutely worth it for a stable society. Of course Croatia is no role model society. Corruption is always widespread. However, we still do have it very good. That is a point that is very frequently understated in Croatia.