3 ms·
Because to truly moderate YouYube, you have to actually watch the videos, and YouTube says they get 500 hours of video uploaded every minute[1], it's pretty eas
by toast0 6y ago
Because to truly moderate YouYube, you have to actually watch the videos, and YouTube says they get 500 hours of video uploaded every minute[1], it's pretty easy to estimate the staffing it would take each video once. They're basically getting 30,000 minutes of video every minute, so if they have 30,000 people watching it, 24/7, it basically works. You need 4.2 fourty hour weeks to cover a whole week, so 126,000 people will do it. They've also report 2 billion monthly users, so around 1:16k moderator:user would get full coverage of videos; plus another team for comments. And of course a team of 1/8th of a million won't manage itself, and you need an escalation path, and non-robot moderator are actually not robots, so they won't (and shouldn't) spend their entire worktime watching.
126,000 workers actually seems reasonable to find, the 2 million you'd need at a 1:1k ratio would be hard, I think. The pay is going to be bad, and the garbage you have to watch won't be worth it for most, but you still need a reasonably analytical person to decide if things definitely follow the rules, definitely don't follow the rules, or need to be escalated. And they need to be attentive, because videos can be totally normal and fine and then get abusive later.
[1] https://blog.youtube/news-and-events/youtube-at-15-my-personal-journey https://blog.youtube/news-and-events/youtube-at-15-my-person...
- dataflow 6y agoThe notion that adequate moderation requires watching every second of video at 1:1 speed is such a strawman on so many levels I don't even know how to respond.
- spiderice 6y agoExactly what I was thinking. There are obviously significantly more effective ways to do things. You could probably just keep the automated systems in place, but have human moderators verify every video that the automated moderators flag (as you stated, obviously not by watching the entire video at 1:1 speed). That alone would be strictly better than how they are currently doing things, and probably not too difficult to pull off.
- throwaway3699 6y agoNote that humans-in-the-loop is the status quo already at YouTube.
- prepend 6y agoYet the humans are making mistakes like this thread is about. I think the intent is to have better humans in the loop and to have a human appeal process. Currently it seems like the human approved removal has no recourse and you’re just hosed.
- spiderice 6y agoI was under the impression that bans were automated, and appeals were handled by humans. I think it would be better if ban “suggestions” were automated and actual bans always came from a human. Not sure the exact process at YouTube though.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- asddubs 6y agoyou would really only need humans that watch things that were reported by humans, not every single video.
- TheSmiddy 6y agoThe human moderators only have to watch what is reported, it is totally unnecessary to watch everything.
- cortic 6y ago126,000 people, assuming a $20,000 annual salary, would be 2.5 billion, or 12.5% of youtubes revenue in 2020. That seems more than reasonable. And when you consider only flagged videos should *need* to be watched by a human.
- danaris 6y ago$20k annually is below poverty line. I'm sure Google would love to be able to get people to solve their moderation problem for so little money they can't actually afford to both eat and pay rent, but if we're making hypotheticals here, we should at last hypothesize 126,000 people who get to live like real human beings.
- cortic 6y agoI'm sorry, i actually had £20k, and just changed it to $ without converting; £20k is about what a 'Accounts Administrator' earns (https://uk.jobted.com/salary https://uk.jobted.com/salary). So that's about $28k which is about 3.5 billion, or about 18% of their 2020 profits. Still very reasonable, most businesses have to put more than half their turnover into wages..
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoThe other thing I'd say is that this isn't low-skill work. If you get thousands of people, train them for a couple days, pay poverty wages and tell them to make each decision in less than 30 seconds, you're not going to get good results.