6 ms·
Obviously, automated (or semi-automated) moderating is absolutely a no-go at scale. I don't think that's obvious at all. You're saying that it's more importan
by onion2k 5y ago
Obviously, automated (or semi-automated) moderating is absolutely a no-go at scale.
I don't think that's obvious at all.
You're saying that it's more important not to remove videos that aren't in violation of the platform's terms, eg false positives in the automated removal process, than it is to remove videos that are, eg actual content that should be removed. Why is it more important that someone's video remains on Facebook than Facebook removes illegal or toxic content? If acceptable videos are removed by mistake is that actually a problem that means the automated process isn't fit for purpose?
... social networks for their ad-hoc censorship...
Facebook removing a video is not censorship. They're not saying "no one can see this video". They're saying "we don't want to host this video". Those are absolutely not the same thing.
- josephcsible 5y ago> Why is it more important that someone's video remains on Facebook than Facebook removes illegal or toxic content? For the same reason that "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer". > Facebook removing a video is not censorship. They're not saying "no one can see this video". They're saying "we don't want to host this video". Those are absolutely not the same thing. Facebook has so much market share that they're uncomfortably close to the same thing.
- vkou 5y ago> For the same reason that "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer". Unfortunately, that is not a mantra that will keep your platform DMCA compliant. Also, how exactly does it apply to an internet mob calling for someone's head? Do we apply this mantra to protect the mob's behaviour, or to protect the person the mob is targeting?
- josephcsible 5y agoThere are plenty of contentious moderation decisions that are unrelated to the DMCA.
- vkou 5y agoWhich is why my post had two parts.
- josephcsible 5y agoFor your second part: by not listening to the mob but not banning them either.
- croon 5y agoGreat personal mantra, terrible preventive policy.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoDMCA compliance is easy. You just have to respond to takedown notices expeditiously. Active moderation for copyright infringement is not required. You don't have to care about infringing content you don't know about if no notice is sent. You can force notices to be mailed to a PO box if that is the desired path for contacting your complaint agent.
- vkou 5y ago> You just have to respond to takedown notices expeditiously. The platforms do just that, by removing the content in question.
- curryst 5y agoMany of the platforms have proactive DMCA applications that actively scan their own content. They have a non-zero false positive rate, although I have no idea what the probability is.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoYouTube has its own non-DMCA process to streamline complaints and satisfy the rights holders who they want to maintain a business relationship with. If you don't have such concerns then basic safe harbor compliance is all you need.
- josephcsible 5y agoNobody complains they do that. The complaint is that that isn't all they do. Sometimes they take down material that they consider infringing without having received a notice, and they often get this wrong.
- watwut 5y ago> For the same reason that "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer". Not even justice system uses that rule.
- unishark 5y agoThe reasonable doubt standard does require the benefit of doubt go towards innocence. Presumably the goal is for more guilty to go free than innocent being punished.
- croon 5y agoIt isn't the goal as much as an unavoidable effect. I however don't feel that comparing video removal to incarceration is relevant. Compare it to traffic rules instead (or anything else you can think of). You have to stop unnecessarily at times, and can't move faster than the speed limit, etc, just because we have deemed the fail state worse than the needless limiting of good drivers' freedoms. I'm not saying which is the case here, but certainly that the argument could be made.
- unishark 5y ago> It isn't the goal as much as an unavoidable effect. I don't see the value of this distinction. Creating a system where it is more likely that guilty go free is the practical equivalent of creating a system where more guilty go free. I wasn't commenting on how well the analogy fits censorship. Though I would note that the criminal justice system doesn't set all people free, just that it adopts a more slanted standard of proof than the laxer standard used in some other judicial situations like civil and immigration courts. The discussion over allowable levels of false positives fits better than a dichotomy comparing a world with traffic laws to anarchy or something.
- watwut 5y agoWhich is different standard. And it applies only in actual trial, which is something quite rare and super expensive. Most of cases are decided outside of trial, where going to trial raises stakes a lot.
- onion2k 5y agoFor the same reason that "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer". That would require someone to believe Facebook taking down a video is equivalent to someone being found guilty of a crime they didn't commit. No one believes that. If Facebook deletes your video that's annoying. It might even affect your livelihood if you've decided to Facebook videos is your chosen career. It isn't the same as being found guilty of a crime you didn't commit. "No false positives at all" is a good and proper goal for the justice system. Facebook's moderation system doesn't need to be held to the same, or even a similar, bar. False positives in video content removal are a very minor problem.
- 5560675260 5y ago> No one believes that. Why not? I don't see a practical difference between Facebook wrongfully labelling a video as abusive and city wrongfully labelling your car as illegally parked. Former might even be more financially damaging.
- selfhoster11 5y ago> No one believes that. Except it does? For people who make their living from Youtube or whatever video platform, removing a video (usually without an appeals process) is basically a punishment regardless of guilt.
- onion2k 5y agoIf Facebook delete a video the author is not being punished because the author has no claim on money they haven't earned yet. It's just the end of a business relationship. Arguing that you're entitled to post on a platform, and to earn money through it, is nonsense. Think of it like this - if I never buy a Starbucks coffee again I am not punishing Starbucks. They don't have any claim on my money, so I am not denying them anything. It's just the end of a business relationship. Facebook are choosing not to buy this guy's videos any more. Arguing that Facebook has a near-monopoly on online video is also nonsense - the guy we're talking about posted on YouTube about this. Clearly he has other options. The number of people who here to argue that they have some sort of 'right' to upload content for Facebook to publish, and that they're being censored and punished if Facebook chooses not to, makes me hope that HN readers never choose to start video hosting platforms. They'd be completely awful.
- klyrs 5y ago> Facebook has so much market share that they're uncomfortably close to the same thing. There's the actual problem. Let's work on that, and preserve the freedom of association.
- josephcsible 5y agoHow exactly do you suppose we do that? Can we do it quickly? If not, should we just let this problem keep happening until it's done?
- klyrs 5y agoI don't claim to know the best way to do this in specific, but generally, I see fb as a monopoly that needs to be broken up, somehow, through antitrust legislation.
- PoignardAzur 5y ago> For the same reason that "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer". That sounds great until the scandals of the type "Someone reposted SFW segments of this girl's revenge porn video and Facebook is taking days to remove them every time; since they're reposted every 24h they stay up forever" roll in. Every so often we get another scandal on HN of the type "This horribly harmful content was posted on PLATFORM and PLATFORM didn't remove it fast enough". Augmenting the false-negative rate would make the problem worse. Attackers can use automation to post their harmful content. There's no way defenders can keep up unless they use automation as well, no matter how decentralized they are.
- josephcsible 5y ago> That sounds great until the scandals of the type "Someone reposted SFW segments of this girl's revenge porn video and Facebook is taking days to remove them every time; since they're reposted every 24h they stay up forever" roll in. This line of argument seems uncomfortably similar to "we need to ban encryption because terrorists and pedophiles can use it". The fact that bad people can occasionally benefit from something isn't a reason to not give it to the rest of us.
- NateEag 5y ago> The fact that bad people can occasionally benefit from something isn't a reason to not give it to the rest of us. It actually can be. There's a continuum. At one extreme are things like plans for nuclear or biological weapons. Nobody distributes those because terrorists really want them for horrible ends and they're of low utility, so we do without them. At the other extreme are things like junk mail - we all just put up with that minor abuse of the system because having a cheap, flexible mail system is way better than not having junk mail. Like I said, it's a spectrum, and sometimes bad people being able to abuse something is a good reason for everyone to forgo it.
- josephcsible 5y ago> At one extreme are things like plans for nuclear or biological weapons. Nobody distributes those because terrorists really want them for horrible ends and they're of low utility, so we do without them. My understanding is that how to build nuclear weapons is relatively well-known, and the only reason that terrorist groups don't have them is that they can't get their hands on the required raw materials.
- nova22033 5y agoFacebook has so much market share that they're uncomfortably close to the same thing. Sorry...market share has nothing to do with their first amendment right to not host content that goes against their policies. Fox News is the most watched cable news network. I wouldn't want the government forcing them to host people they don't want to host.
- dvt 5y ago> Why is it more important that someone's video remains on Facebook than Facebook removes illegal or toxic content? This is a straw-man; that's not what I'm saying at all. In fact, I'm arguing that you can probably have both -- by using human moderators. > Facebook removing a video is not censorship. It is censorship. They're saying "no one can see this video on our platform." Do you really want to get in some silly semantic debate when you know full well what I meant? It seems you're being purposefully uncharitable.
- afarrell 5y ago> when you know full well what I meant Reminder: humans lack telepathy and so they depend on body language, tone, and word semantics to communicate.
- unishark 5y agoIt isn't really a semantic issue. Removing someone's communication from your site is literally censorship. It's simply not govt censorship. But censorship by quasi-monopolies makes it arguably similar and still an ethics debate.
- onion2k 5y agoAre you suggesting that video platforms should not be allowed to remove content? That's a very extreme point of view.
- unishark 5y agoThere are two sides in the debate I referred to and my post did not advocate either side.
- MikeUt 5y agoI want to highlight the very common, very dishonest debate trick you just performed. You skipped right past calling the thing for what it is (censorship), past admitting it's a problem, and you're now arguing against a hypothetical extreme solution no-one has yet proposed. Can we assume that you now agree it's censorship, and that it's a problem, and it's only the solution you proposed that bothers you?