3 ms·
Money only needs to be a few things. 1. Cheap, fast and easy to transact + broadly accepted. 2. Fungible. 3. Predictable. 4. Hold its value for exactly as l
by arcticbull 5y ago
Money only needs to be a few things.
1. Cheap, fast and easy to transact + broadly accepted.
2. Fungible.
3. Predictable.
4. Hold its value for exactly as long as it takes you to convert your earnings into either long-term value storage assets, or to spend on the necessities of life. Any longer is a non-goal.
5. [bonus] Flexible enough to respond to shocks, changes and externalities, offering mild, predictable inflation as measured against a basket of necessities.
Every crypto fails 1, 3, 4 and 5 - and all the popular ones fail (2) also - as a public ledger revealing a coins history makes each transaction quantum unique.
No idea why you got down-voted, the article is totally wrong.
- fastball 5y ago1. There are plenty of cryptos that this applies to right now. Cheap is not true for ETH atm, but it may soon be given the very real scaling solutions that are soon to come online. 2. Why does a means of exchange need to be fungible? Regardless, Monero and others are fungible. 3. Not sure what this means or why its required for money, but still seems like crypto can apply here. 4. Stablecoins exist, and I'm not even counting the shady AF ones like Tether. For example there is DAI, which is fully decentralized, runs on the Ethereum blockchain, has held stable very well (certainly well enough for the above use case) and which saw $2.6B trade volume in the last 24hr.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jkhdigital 5y agoNice list, but it seems kind of like a straw man specifically constructed to claim that cryptocurrencies fail to meet it. Anyways, I don’t understand your extreme hard-line stance on holding money. You do realize that liquidity is important, right? Holding uninvested cash sends two important signals: that I want a buffer against adverse events without having to liquidate assets, and/or that none of the currently available investment opportunities meets my desired risk/reward criteria. These are extremely important market signals that get squashed when you abuse your money supply to bully everyone into being 110% invested at all times, good or bad.
- arcticbull 5y agoI agree some amount of cash is worth holding, and the 2% annualized inflation you pay is simply a fee for liquidity. It harms the economy but benefits you, so a fee doesn't seem unreasonable. I didn't construct the list specifically to attack cryptocurrencies, the whole crypto situation has led me to do a lot of research on just what a reasonable monetary policy is.