3 ms·
I think families with kids being impacted there particularly. Yes, one example that is not widely known of what happens when the Lions of the Left have the pow
by SiVal 5y ago
I think families with kids being impacted there particularly.
Yes, one example that is not widely known of what happens when the Lions of the Left have the power to do what they really want is public middle school algebra in SF. ("The Lion of the Left" was the self-given nickname of one of SF's most-loved talk show hosts back in the 90s.)
SF grandees noticed that some races tended to take geometry (the class after algebra I) more than others. The number one goal of public education, they claimed, was to "close the achievement gap", so they eliminated geometry from middle school. If no one took it, no one who didn't take it would be behind, so no gap.
But then they noticed that some races still took algebra I more often than other races. So they eliminated that, too. [1] No one, no matter how well prepared, would be allowed to take algebra in any public middle school. The best students would be required to take the same classes as the worst, for great justice. Achievement gap closed.
Except that better students still had four years in high school to try to catch up to where they would have been if not held back, and not all races were equally likely to do this.
So, for more justice, all public schools in SF were required to keep their best math students in the same classes with the worst all the way from K-10. They are now only allowed to be different individuals the final two years of HS. Anyone who wants to take calculus in a SF high school now has to scramble to cram two years (algebra II/trig & pre-calc) into 11th grade to (poorly) prepare for calculus in 12th--until that miscarriage of justice can be eliminated, too.
Those who can afford it go to work at tech companies where they use various means to silence the "haters" who resist, while sending their own children to private schools that don't have these policies.
Many of those who can't afford it have been moving out of the city to suburbs that have begun the process (lots of districts have now eliminated middle school geometry and advanced placement classes) but are still lagging behind SF in implementing full justice. (Big Tech is working on it, but pockets of resistance remain.)
SF Chronicle, a big proponent of policies like this, describes it as positively as they can:
[1] https://www.sfchronicle.com/education/article/SF-schools-move-to-delay-algebra-shows-13518860.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/education/article/SF-schools-mov...
- slownews45 5y agoI think there will be some state standards that will get rid of calculus in high school. I'm not actually against that, I never thought it was such as big deal. Other parts of the standards (focus on group work, and on racial justice work in math) which may be designed in part to help reduce achievement gap do raise some questions around preparedness of some students that would result. This will only work if they get rid of standardized testing I think in later years (college admissions etc).
- Aa9C4xPz43Gg7k6 5y agoGroup work doesn't exist in the school. It's always 1 person doing everything and others freeloading on their work.
- Aa9C4xPz43Gg7k6 5y agoActivists have long history of destroying good schools, all that matters is ideology and feel good activism, consequences be damned. See Dunbar High School history mentioned by Sowell: before and after dismantling segregation. SF Chronicle is pure propaganda.