4 ms·
Yes. As a physician, I wish more folks appreciated that “disability” is a property of the relationship between a person and their environment, and can emerge (
by wittyreference 5y ago
Yes.
As a physician, I wish more folks appreciated that “disability” is a property of the relationship between a person and their environment, and can emerge (or disappear) based on changes in that persons capability as well as changes in their environment.
For an obvious example: a patient with reversible heart failure can’t walk without severe shortness of breath today, but they can in three months. Today they need disabled parking; three months from now they do not.
- tolbish 5y agoCan we apply "disability" to all abilities, like being hungover and therefore temporarily sensitive to light and sound, or should it apply to specific ones, like being injured and therefore temporarily sensitive to light and sound?
- _jal 5y agoI don't know what a doctor would say here. Just noting that medical jargon sometimes carries moral or legal tones independent of any actual medical distinction. For instance if you're taking a legal drug that habituates you, they don't like calling you an addict, so you're experiencing cessation syndrome. A change in legal status of the drug would presumably lead to a terminology change. And I'm not going to revisit DSM fights, but suffice to say, a number of changes made to certain diagnoses over time reveal more about sociopolitical changes than anything having to do with psychiatry.
- nkmnz 5y agoYour statement regarding legal status of a drug and addiction is wrong. Alcohol and tobacco are legal drugs and you can not only evolve a dependency on them, but if your addicted you’ll be called an addict. The same is true for other legal drugs used as medication, e.g. benzodiazepines or opioids. If you’ve developed physical and/or psychological dependence on such a drug, you might suffer from withdrawal, which is not a different thing than discontinuation, but rather a special case thereof. Addiction and withdrawal compare to dependency and discontinuation like a hoarder compares to someone who relies on the service of a cleaning lady.
- _jal 5y agoI won't argue the point, it very much is not my area. But that is not the understanding I left with when I quizzed my doctor on the topic.
- Judgmentality 5y agoYou are really hung up on trying to reconcile that 'disability' has a different meaning in an English dictionary as from a court of law. In different contexts, the word will mean different things. When in doubt, provide additional details to alleviate any confusion - this will vary on a case by case basis.
- tolbish 5y agoThe meaning of words will always depend on the context they are used in. Even outside of a court of law, there are still people here who disagree that a person with an occupied hand is still disabled. That seems like something that will shift towards one or the other as society talks more openly about disabilities.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- microtherion 5y agoI'd probably call that a "hands busy" situation rather than a disability situation, but some of the same computer features may be helpful for both situations.
- villasv 5y agoIn the language of product design and experience, yes you can apply to all abilities. More specifically, all abilities required by your product.
- sethjgore 5y agoExactly! I am deaf and when I’m in an environment that’s fully signed, I cease to be disabled. Truly! And those who aren’t signing-aware in such environments become disabled language-wise.
- noneeeed 5y agoThat reminds me of a time I went to the pub with friends after work. I was sat at the table with my back to the rest of the pub. After a while I though "wow it's really quite in here tonight" at which point I turned around to find that the pub was packed, but with deaf people all signing to each other. Turns out it was a monthly deaf meetup at the pub. It really demonstrated your point. I was quite jealous of their ability to hold a conversation with people all the way across the pub :)