3 ms·
> Doesn't every ISP do this? No. Most ISPs overprovision. e.g. my Spectrum service is nominally 600Mbit but actually supports 680. This is done because a) user
by dboreham 5y ago
> Doesn't every ISP do this?
No. Most ISPs overprovision. e.g. my Spectrum service is nominally 600Mbit but actually supports 680. This is done because a) users often measure payload throughput vs wire throughput and there's a ~10% packet overhead, and b) to avoid customer complaints at the margin.
- hellotomyrars 5y agoThis is accurate in my experience working for numerous ISPs. Especially with DSL service, lines were often overprovisioned up to 20%. I also gained a lot of insight into the tools available to support staff and they varied quite a bit. I even worked on a contract with Frontier for a few months. The service they offered for former Verizon FIOS customers was decent, but DSL customers were treated like crap. Unless a customer went out of their way to make multiple contact attempts and demand to escalate multiple times, they would be largely ignored in any situation that required a truck roll. The company truly did not care and it's obvious nothing has changed (Except maybe for the worse) since I worked that contract. Of the ISPs I worked with I actually found Centurylink to have the best tools and best service. Personally I've been stuck with comcast for most of the last decade so I've never been the customer but the support staff was generally pretty well trained at the time and they had a lot of information available about the line status, as well as direct interface with the CPE. They were in a transition to off-shore support at the time though, and it was clear that the quality of service provided by the off-shore agents was much lower. They were very clearly trained off a tight script and were woefully incapable of handling situations that didn't fit the script.
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoThis isn’t entirely the whole story. Every ISP oversubscribes. OP is correct. Overprovision is a different thing. You are talking about getting 680 so that when you speedtest, you have NOTHING to complain about to them. This is basically part of their boost and oversub plan, where it isn’t hurting them so they toss you a bone to preempt speed complaints. What you aren’t told is that Spectrum also does short term speed boosting. For 30S-1min you’ll get 680, but it will fall in PRIORITY after that. This also conveniently helps speed tests. At 3am, you’ll get a solid 680 real world. At 6pm, you’re more likely to get a sustained 680 for a bit, then fall to 400 or so. You need a transfer at max speed to show this. Newsgroups are good for maxing a connection and showing the fall-off decline of a boosted connection. Spectrum only started this in my area a year ago or so. After an initially great move to DOCSIS 3.1. Oversubscribing means that if Spectrum has 2TB of bandwidth, they’ll sell 3TB knowing that all their customers won’t concurrently use it. It would be a statistically unlikelihood. TRUST ME, they do the math on this. If you add all the 600Mbps users up, you’ll get to a number they can not possibly support. This is OK. What the issue that Frontier seems to be in trouble with is they went way too far, and couldn’t hit the base numbers they were offering. But YES, every ISP out there I ever felt with while in telecom does in fact oversubscribe.
- anticristi 5y ago> It would be a statistically unlikelihood. TRUST ME, they do the math on this. Is that really how it works? I was working for a small-town ISP and our approach was: Boss link A is at 50% and will fill up within a month. Shall upgrade the converters? I mean, you could argue that we did math, i.e., linear prediction on statistical aggregate values, but this was not synced with sales or marketing, rather done out-of-band.
- vel0city 5y ago50% of actual usage or subscribed throughput?
- anticristi 5y ago50% of actual usage. We had no integration between NOC and sales, so we had no clue about subscribed throughput. Also, network topology -- e.g. redundant paths -- made the mapping between customers and network pretty tricky. I'm talking here about access network and core network, not last mile.
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoThe contractor I was with, yes, definitely. It sounds from your other comment it was a smaller ISP you were at. We definitely had the data from NOC and Sales and watched them figure out what hardware they would need for the next few quarters based on their oversubscribe estimations. Edit: lol; I worked in telecom. I’m sorry first hand experiences make some of you so mad.