6 ms·
I have anecdotes both for and against this from women who were on the internet before anything that could be considered a “women in tech” movement existed. I c
by dijit 6y ago
I have anecdotes both for and against this from women who were on the internet before anything that could be considered a “women in tech” movement existed.
I can’t say from a male perspective. But I think it’s not as black and white as you paint it.
The (consistent) impression I was given was that if you didn’t try to constantly talk about being a girl/woman the majority of people just didn’t really care.
There is, however, a sad truth of the internet: that people are free to try to antagonise anyone they want without major repercussions; being a woman is something to bring up if you are one of those. But those people would find another reason anyway, I truly don’t believe it’s “because” a person is female.
So “male passing”, on IRC, about technical topics, is “human passing” in most cases, and when it’s not, nobody seems to really care, or that’s what I’ve been told.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoMost people not caring isn't the problem though, because it doesn't take that many people to constantly harass someone.
- falcolas 6y agoA lot of times, announcing that you're a woman on the internet was (is still?) seen as a request to be treated differently. This is how "Tits or GTFO" came about. i.e. denigrating yourself is the only way to be treated differently from everyone else. I'm not entirely sure if we've progressed or regressed from that.
- duckfang 6y agoWeirdly enough, "Tits or GTFO" was primarily a 4chan-ism. Everybody was "anonymous", so if someone claimed to be a woman, she needed to show tits. Thats not to say I've never seen discrimination of any sort on irc. It's usually troll behaviors I see there, and general hate.
- ljm 6y agoIs it not apparent in the description that you were also assumed male by default, then? I don't recall 'cock and balls or GTFO' being a thing. The point being that whatever noble intention was behind this anonymity, the simple fact of being a woman (or not a man) was enough to make you stand out. Therefore, a woman would have fewer problems if they either kept their own gender out of it, played along with the guys who would happily talk about women in questionable ways, or stuck only to conversations where all of that could remain ambiguous.
- thefunnyman 6y agoRule 29: On the internet men are men, women are also men, and kids are undercover FBI agents.
- duckfang 6y agoWhen the more puerile culture of The September that Never Ended happened, we saw most of this machismo garbage take hold. Myself, having access to AoL for a time, saw what that place was like and agreed it was a seething cesspool. Sexist, racist, homophobic diatribes were *everywhere* on AoL. Most heated arguments you'd get on the internet proper were the gnu vs bsd, or vi vs emacs. Prior to that infamous date, either the custom was Mr. or Sir, or the like. Or, more commonly, was whatever nickname you chose for yourself. Some names have a more feminine sound, while others had more masculine. Yet more were androgynous. Yet when AoL decided to become the gateway to the internet, is when we saw that "average" (aka: racist, sexist, homophobic, different-phobic) people join for the first time, the old guard of the internet didn't know how to handle it - we've always dealt with a higher class of people, and these distinctly weren't it. It really didn't start turning really bad until these Web 2.0 companies started linking payment gateways to real names. Overnight, your account would be locked/banned for "fake names or transgender names"... And companies like Facebook would use your friends as that proof. And of course, we know how all that is turning out - it's just as unsafe for women (or really anyone "different") walking on a sidewalk as it is with their real name online. Fortunately, there's still fringes on the internet. I don't know if you're male, female, young, old, disabled, ,black, white, native, asian, from a different country, etc.... If we leave it out of the discussion, its unimportant. HN is most definitely not one of those areas, as the assumption is that you're a white, probably male, tech worker, and that you're happy with venture capital and startups. (I really don't want to mention those quieter areas, as it reminds us of our old ideas of the internet and all the wonders we imagined it could do... Unlike today's marketing hell, capitalistic cesspool, and emotional monetization. It doesn't have to be like that.)
- panopticon 6y agoIt likely originated there, but I observed it all over the place. MMOs, IRC, other message boards, etc. From my experience, it was a common fixture of the late 2000s internet culture.
- elliekelly 6y ago> A lot of times, announcing that you're a woman on the internet was (is still?) seen as a request to be treated differently. This is the problem, isn’t it? The women who state (not “announce” - never in my 25+ years on the internet have I attended an anon user gender reveal) their gender online and then dare to request they’re treated the same as their peers. They want to be treated differently than women are usually treated online. Equal to male and anon users.
- elliekelly 6y ago> The (consistent) impression I was given was that if you didn’t try to constantly talk about being a girl/woman the majority of people just didn’t really care. Not mentioning your gender when you have a gender-neutral username means people “don’t really care” you’re a woman because they just assume you’re a man. But often the mere mention of the fact you’re a woman, however relevant to the discussion, is viewed as “constantly talking about” your gender.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- splithalf 6y agoWhen is it ever not relevant? It’s all most humans can think of, arguably for valid if not good reasons.
- wyclif 5y agoThe (consistent) impression I was given was that if you didn’t try to constantly talk about being a girl/woman the majority of people just didn’t really care That sounds right to me, and matches up with my experiences back then. Nobody really cared as long as you weren't trying to make it the basis of your identity and constantly talking about it. A lot of women didn't want to announce their gender because they didn't want special treatment. Of course in some cases that meant sexual attention, but the difference between then and now was that there wasn't as much sexual harassment and fear online.