3 ms·
The fact some people will do something voluntarily doesn't mean it's ethical to force other people to do it against their will. Therefore, it's irrelevant whet
by michaelt 5y ago
The fact some people will do something voluntarily doesn't mean it's ethical to force other people to do it against their will.
Therefore, it's irrelevant whether "regular people do it voluntarily" - because it's the being forced against their will that's the ethical issue here.
One illustrative example of this maxim is prostitution.
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoBut isn't that deliberately ignoring the fact we're talking about prisoners? Not citizens with full rights? So 'making them do something' is the entire point of the exercise. Its not advancing the topic to exclaim breathlessly about loss of rights, when that's the point of prison. We could be talking about misaligned incentives or effectiveness etc.