4 ms·
Is prison labor bad in all cases? By letting prisoners become familiar with expectations of a job, and get used to being paid, managing finances, and spending
by londons_explore 6y ago
Is prison labor bad in all cases?
By letting prisoners become familiar with expectations of a job, and get used to being paid, managing finances, and spending within their means, they're less likely to be forced to return to crime after they're released.
Despite being 'inhumane', I suspect these programmes lead to better outcomes for people involved in them than prisoners who spend every day in a cell.
Is there data to prove or disprove my hypothesis?
- Peckingjay 6y agoNot in all cases, but when coupled with the private prison system of the US which is less concerned with rehabilitation and more with the extraction of value from its "residents", you do get a problem.
- yesenadam 6y agoWell, I guess if you compare prison labour vs nothing, like that, then it sounds all good. If you compare slave/underpaid labour vs proper-wage labour, then it's probably putting people out of a job. Also, it sounds like the last thing the US needs is more commercial incentive to put people in prison.
- slumber86 6y agoFrom the piece: "incarcerated people working for the state’s correctional industries earn an average of $4.50 per day."
- simiones 6y agoEven if you were absolutely correct about improved outcomes (I don't know what/if the data shows), there is still a major problem that would still make prison labor as it exists today problematic or even immoral: it creates a huge incentive to imprison more people through various means (stricter laws, opposition to drug reform, mandatory minimums etc.). The prison industrial complex is a major lobby for these issues, so this is not just a theoretical concern. A system that would improve the life of people after prison without falling for this pitfall would have to entirely remove the profit motive from prison labor (for example by prohibiting the prison to keep any proceeds from prison labor, or by paying inmates competitive rates for the work they are doing, so that overall prison labor is guaranteed to be more expensive than just hiring/outsourcing etc).
- FriedrichN 6y agoI would be fine with it if there was no profit made, or the profits would go to rehabilitation of these individuals. Being able to make a profit off prison labor is a bad incentive. Kind of how America went from the slave labor system to the prison labor system seamlessly. There was just too much money to be made.
- bryanrasmussen 6y ago>By letting prisoners become familiar with expectations of a job, and get used to being paid, managing finances, and spending within their means, they're less likely to be forced to return to crime after they're released. I would expect there are large percentages of the prison population that might be familiar with these things, also I mean the expectation a job in prison might be getting you ready for is a low paid job in which you are exploited, which once having been in prison in the U.S is probably what you can expect - but I don't know if having that expectation will actually reduce recidivism.
- miskin 6y agoI actually know people that had some business inside prison in EU country and the experience was that there were more prisoners asking to be working than it was possible to use. Main driving force was that time passes faster when you are busy, with another advantage that earned money could be used to buy some extra goods. Also, some of the former prisoners continued to work in that company once their prison time was over, so it was really good help in transition to freedom. Since prison work is voluntary, there is not much space for exploitation.
- sokoloff 6y agoThere’s clearly space for exploitation if you allow the overall system to adjust the number of people becoming prisoners.
- jiofih 6y agoThat’s mostly a North American problem though, the commenter is from the EU. Work is opt-in.
- bryanrasmussen 6y ago>I actually know people that had some business inside prison in EU country ok but there does seem to be some perception in the world that the prisons in the U.S might be slightly lacking in some of the human rights protections found in EU prisons - you are aware of this concern right? >Since prison work is voluntary, there is not much space for exploitation. Again, speaking about the U.S, and I know that in Utah prison work is not exactly voluntary in that the parole board has power to release or make stay to your maximum sentence - so in Utah you go in with a possible 1-15 years, if the parole board wants to let you go in 1 year you can go (but of course be on parole and get pulled back in again later if considered necessary), so how do you get the parole board to consider letting you out in 1 year instead of 15 - well you get a job and work every day and show them that you are good. Other tools are of course used for compliance and to make people work. This is of course one state and things vary by state the American system, but there are plenty of states considered much worse than Utah for prisoner exploitation so in conclusion, I know things are great in the EU is not going to calm any worries in a discussion about the US.
- 1_person 6y agoWould it be bad if you were the prisoner?
- gambiting 6y agoConsider that with the perverse incentives you might become a prisoner because the state and/or private company needs more cheap labour.
- antihero 6y agoCould also serve as a reminder to people that despite the risks of crime, a banal job is basically just a punishment. I think if I wasn't a programmer and only had the skills to work a minimum wage job, crime would absolutely seem more rational.
- kstenerud 6y agoIt was fine when the prisoners themselves were the only ones using the things they produced. The problem comes when the fruits of this labor are sold on the market. Then all of the perverse incentives rear their ugly heads. Whenever you have a captive consumer or producer of marketable materials, you have a perverse incentive to exploit, because the other party has no choice in the matter and must take whatever you offer (if anything). Every dystopian movie makes heavy use of these kinds of story elements. In the case of prison labor, you essentially have slaves, and can therefore leverage that slave labor to undercut your competitors in the open market. The slaves, meanwhile, suffer the indignity of their forced labor and exploitation for someone else's benefit, which is why we outlawed slavery in the civilised parts of the world. In the case of captive markets (food, commissary, communications systems, etc), price gouging is commonplace. Food quality is so low that malnutrition is common. Quality is shit but it doesn't matter because the consumers of these products are not empowered to decide, while everyone else involved benefits from their exploitation and therefore has no incentive to fix it. This is then further exacerbated by trade groups that influence laws to increase incarceration durations and incidence in order to preserve and even expand their supply of captives for further exploitation and profit. I suggest you look into how Western European countries handle their prison populations for comparison.
- jiofih 6y agoI don’t see how selling to the outside world is a problem in itself. It connects with the community and gives the workers a much more fulfilling sense of accomplishment than doing it as a hobby. What you described only holds true if: 1. There is nobody overseeing policies regarding prices, compensation and workloads. 2. The “business” or workforce can be grown to increase profit 3. Work is mandatory Both 1 and 2 point to a private prison system being a problem. They have little oversight, and are incentivized to increase the # if prisoners instead of it being an expense.
- kstenerud 6y agoSelling to the outside world is not a problem PROVIDED the producer of said products can set the asking price for their labor and the (free) market itself dictates what they can get. This is never the case with prison systems, public or private.
- de_keyboard 6y agoIn that sense it is not bad. The problem is that it creates perverse financial incentives for large sections of the population to be incarcerated as a cheap supply of labour. Prison labour also undercuts minimum wages in some cases. Consider that for-profit prison companies spend millions of dollars on lobbying efforts.
- jdasdf 6y agoThe problem is the incentives they create to imprison people. Imprisoning someone should be a purely negative action on the state, by having some potential benefit you reduce the costs imposed to the state and therefore incentivize imprisonment.
- watwut 6y ago> By letting prisoners become familiar with expectations of a job, and get used to being paid, managing finances, and spending within their means, they're less likely to be forced to return to crime after they're released. Afaik, prisons jobs in general do nothing of the sort.
- nunoonun 6y ago> Is prison labor bad in all cases? Yes, all prison labor is bad in all cases. Why? It's very simple, you're creating a market that incentivizes incarceration. Prison should be about recovery of a human being and trying to create negative incentives so people think about making a crime (this is a bit debatable). When you create a market for incarceration, what you're saying is "we don't want to lower crime". So yes, it's bad in all cases because we should be creating incentives to lower crime instead of how to make it profitable.
- risyachka 6y agoPrisons don’t incarcerate people. If the money from sales go to prisons and inmates then there is no incentives for judges or prosecutors to incarcerate anyone. If money somehow are connected - this should probably be changed. The fact of selling products to the market is not a problem here.
- nunoonun 6y agoBecause lobbying is illegal, right?
- Avshalom 6y agoMaybe slave labor is good 'cause convicts don't know about jobs is a pretty impressively fucked "hypothesis"