3 ms·
I don't think everyone sees it as just a "children" issue - it's not like the topic doesn't come up when it's about adults. But children is the angle laws can h
by detaro 6y ago
I don't think everyone sees it as just a "children" issue - it's not like the topic doesn't come up when it's about adults. But children is the angle laws can hit the easiest, and it does hit an extra "think of the children" emotional spot. And mental health among adults is more of a taboo topic politically. So I think it is a mix.
- goldcd 6y agoTo disagree, I don't think the topic does come up when discussing (voting) adults. Does your politican campaign on a policy that specifically sets out reduces self-harm or suicide in their adult electorate? "Let me be judged if I don't reduce suicides by 5% in my term!" No. Because that's not what we want to hear. We want to be left alone with our guns and alcohol, but by all means help me with my teenager listening to "rap music" or being upset as her bullying classmate was unkind to her on tiktok.
- nearbuy 6y agoThe U.S. did ban alcohol once. It didn't go over well.
- goldcd 6y agoand I believe it did reduce suicide rates. I think if I had to summarize, voters will vote to give themselves choices (however harmful) - whilst patting themselves on the back for voting to restrict others for their own protection.
- nearbuy 6y agoI completely agree. There's an additional aspect, though. Voters will vote against new restrictions for themselves, but will vote to keep existing restrictions that have been around a long time. A fun example (quoted from https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/01/11/self-serving-bias https://slatestarcodex.com/2018/01/11/self-serving-bias): > Oregon is one of two US states that bans self-service gas stations. Recently, they passed a law relaxing this restriction – self-service is permissible in some rural counties during odd hours of the night. Outraged Oregonians took to social media to protest that self-service was unsafe, that it would destroy jobs, that breathing in gas fumes would kill people, that gas pumping had to be performed by properly credentialed experts – seemingly unaware that most of the rest of the country and the world does it without a second thought. So maybe we like freedoms that we're used to, but also like the benefits (or perceived benefits in the above example) of restrictions that we're used to. (I don't know if disapproval of allowing self-service was widespread or was just a small number of people posting on social media, but it makes a good story.)
- jVinc 6y agoThe data being used to back this is very much a "children" issue, a adolescent female issue to be exact. The rate of depression stated to skyrocket in 2012 for this specific group. This also seems to be an obvious counter to the implied hypothesis that "rate of depression increases linearly with facebook usage" since they launched in like 2005 or so, grew steadily from at least 2007, and also have most likely seen a significant decline in usage among adolescents in the recent years.
- captaincaveman 6y agoYou could arguably better correlate that with teenagers gaining access to personal image sharing devices .. i.e. camera phones, and publishing platforms i.e. they can share photos/videos ... systemically the issue is self worth being largely wrapped up in how pretty you are perceived to be, which is a social/cultural problem.