5 ms·
>We set out to build something much more than a large iPhone app on a bigger screen. We had to completely rethink our design to for the big, bigger and biggest
by rasz 6y ago
>We set out to build something much more than a large iPhone app on a bigger screen. We had to completely rethink our design to for the big, bigger and biggest portable screen.
>The best UI is usually as little as you can get away with, so just like on Halide for iPad, our exposure dials only appear while adjusting exposure. They fade away into the background after a few moments.
we had to think what to do with all of this extra screen space, so we decided to hide even more of the UI
- sandofsky 6y agoAs mentioned in the post, when the viewfinder fills the screen, controls have to overlap the viewfinder. This makes it harder to judge your composition. That's why it still makes sense to keep your UI from looking like an airplane cockpit.
- LeoPanthera 6y agoSo don't fill the screen with the viewfinder. It's not rocket science.
- sandofsky 6y agoAs explained in the post, there’s a button to toggle that.
- LeoPanthera 6y agoYes I know. (Edit: You edited your comment so now I am forced to edit mine. Yours previously said something like "that's an intentional feature called 'ProView' described in the article".) I'm disputing this part of the article: > The best UI is usually as little as you can get away with I think this is what designers honestly believe, and obviously you do too. I just don't think it's true. I know that undiscoverable UIs have been a trend for a while now, and I wonder how much damage they have done to human productivity and the reputation of software developers in general. It's possible your goal is to make an intentionally difficult-to-use app, so that people are forced to learn the tricks and secrets, and then eventually feel "invested" in the app after they have done so, making it less likely for them to switch. Snapchat does this. But this is a photography app, not a trendy social network for Generation Z, and so the decision to make it intentionally hide UI controls from you is, in my opinion, completely crazy.
- sandofsky 6y agoI'm not the designer, but here goes... "As little as you can get away with," includes a discoverable UI. We go to great lengths to make things discoverable. For starters, there's a chevron providing a visual affordance, reminding you the QuickBar and Honeycomb are expandable with a swipe. But we go even further. The first few times you launch they app, the UI starts with the QuickBar expanded. After a few moments, it closes, which will likely draw the user's attention. Once you've used the app a few times, we don't show this helpful animation to remind you that the QuickBar is expandable. The client also tracks if you haven't launched the app in a while, and brings back that helpful animation. (This is all tracked client-side in the name of privacy.) > It's possible your goal is to make an intentionally difficult-to-use app, so that people are forced to learn the tricks and secrets, and then eventually feel "invested" in the app after they have done so, making it less likely for them to switch. Snapchat does this. If that were my goal, I would be a moron. Snapchat is successful in spite of its incomprehensible UI due to network effects and its value proposition. If you've watched SnapChat's UI evolve over the years, they've trended toward more discoverability. You can only go so far with the novelty of a mystery box. We have no network effects. We don't lock away your data. We live and die by our UI. There are many other apps that have similar features as us, with many customers telling us they tried all the other apps before settling on us. If you don't like the UI, that's perfectly fine. You're welcome to your opinion. It just doesn't line up with the opinion of our customers.
- AmVess 6y agoExactly this. Hiding a UI behind a UI behind a UI is nothing but painful and slow. I downloaded the app and was met with two subscription options and a purchase option. You cannot try the app free without choosing one of two subscription options or a rather silly purchase price of $40 USD. Requiring a subscription signup before using software is Scuzzware...they are betting you forget you downloaded it and signed up for the sub. I have an extremely dim view of this practice. Strike 1. They have UI hidden under UI. Strike 2. UI buttons unmarked with no clear indication as to function. Strike 3 and uninstalled.
- sandofsky 6y agoPreviously, we offered a pay-once price with no trial option. With subscriptions, trials are straightforward, solve the App Store’s lack of upgrade options, and open the door to features with ongoing costs. It would be nice if Apple offered Sketch style licensing, but it is what it is. If you don’t want to go with a subscription, we still offer a pay-once choice. Just be aware that you won’t get features with ongoing costs. If the price doesn’t make sense to you, then it sounds like you’ll be happier with a cheaper app, and we wish you best.
- sbierwagen 6y agoI was under the impression that the app store payment model makes it impossible to do a time-limited trial. You either have a lite version that lasts forever, or a pro version which requires up-front payment, no tryout possible.
- whoisburbansky 6y agoHalide offers a 7-day trial, I don't know where you're getting the idea that the app store makes time-limited trials impossible from.
- girvo 5y agoThose trials only work with subscriptions, at least as far as I understand it. The trial just delays billing. This makes Sketch style pricing and trial behaviour difficult.