11 ms·
California Tries to “Cancel Math Class”
- zepto 6y agoSeems like a victory for an influence operation aimed at destroying the United States.
- noofen 6y agoThat is the true goal. China sits back and laughs.
- adamrezich 6y agomore and more current events seem to fit this profile
- CodeGlitch 6y ago...or any Western country. See here for the influences China is having with British Universities: https://www.theguardian.com/education/2019/nov/05/alarming-chinese-meddling-at-uk-universities-exposed-in-report https://www.theguardian.com/education/2019/nov/05/alarming-c... It wouldn't surprise me if the whole woke culture was dreamt up by China/Russia, or they seized upon it seeing it as a way to gain an advantage. Clever really, I'll give them that.
- babaganoosh89 6y agoWhile the premise of the article is sickening, I'd take opinion articles from WSJ with a big grain of salt. Their general reporting tends to be somewhat neutral, but their opinion articles tend to be invasively slanted and spun.
- WalterBright 6y agoWhat major newspaper doesn't engage in that in their opinion pieces? In this case, the editorial provides numerous references. Read the references and form your own opinions.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoYou can see the source material here: https://equitablemath.org/ https://equitablemath.org/ What is this nonsense? > The Pathway offers guidance and resources for educators to use now as they plan their curriculum, while also offering opportunities for ongoing self-reflection as they seek to develop an anti-racist math practice. The toolkit “strides” serve as multiple on-ramps for educators as they navigate the individual and collective journey from equity to anti-racism.
- jgwil2 6y agoFrom the first paragraph of the FAQ: > For decades, America’s schools have tried and failed to close gaps on math test scores between White students and students of color. That’s not because math discriminates by race, and it’s not because some groups of students are inherently more suited to math. It’s because we give students of color and students from lower-income families the least access to critical resources, from the most qualified teachers to the best technology to the most advanced courses. And it’s because instructional materials and practices—even good ones—are influenced by culture and perspective. Is it just me, or does that sound pretty reasonable?
- lotsofpulp 6y agoSure, but it has nothing to do with race. Addressing challenges faced by children who grow up with poorer or less educated parents is fine. I do not see why race is brought into the discussion, other than to grab attention, at which I guess it was successful.
- thatswrong0 6y agoA lot of the systemic issues that have caused people of certain races to be poorer and less educated have either a historical or direct basis in race. And then if you look then at the poverty rates by race, it's clear that certain policies (esp. with regards to educational funding) often have a far worse impact on members of a certain race than others. It's not hard to make a connection between, say, an actually racist issue like redlining and how it affected the development of neighborhoods, and the subsequent lack of local funding for educational programs in the affected neighborhoods.
- ThrowawayR2 6y agoThe parent poster does have a point; the Wikipedia entry for the author indicates that he identified politically as a Libertarian and later Republican: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Williamson_Evers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Williamson_Evers which is a likely bias. We should be careful to draw conclusions only after reading the source material that the opinion piece is quoting from.
- zepto 6y agoNo, the parent is just making a standard ad-hominem which adds no value to discussion of the content.
- jxramos 6y agoIs this a serious piece or is this some kind of parody?
- hangonhn 6y agoIt's an op-ed piece on WSJ. Op-ed piece is just that, someone's opinions. They don't have the same journalistic standards as real news articles. My personal preference is to generally avoid all op-ed pieces and if I do read them, I would be very critical of them. My only advice is that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Op-eds tends to be low on the evidence vs claims ratio.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ajhurliman 6y agoAre you rejecting the notion that the CA Board of Education is seriously considering a revision of their math program? It seems like they linked to the "extraordinary evidence" in the first paragraph: https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/ma/cf/index.asp https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/ma/cf/index.asp
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lotsofpulp 6y agoUnfortunately, the serious part is this nonsense is being discussed by leadership in the educational system of some stages.
- BitwiseFool 6y ago"It sets forth indicators of “white supremacy culture in the mathematics classroom,” including a focus on “getting the right answer,” teaching math in a “linear fashion,” requiring students to “show their work” and grading them on demonstrated knowledge of the subject matter. “The concept of mathematics being purely objective is unequivocally false,” the manual explains. “Upholding the idea that there are always right and wrong answers perpetuates ‘objectivity.’ ” This scares and angers me in a way that I am struggling to express.
- inglor_cz 6y agoThe neo-racist idea that rational thinking and scientific culture is an expression of "whiteness" creeps out of the woodwork again and again. Remember the infographics that the Smithsonian National Museum of African American History and Culture published and later withdrew? https://www.newsweek.com/smithsonian-race-guidelines-rational-thinking-hard-work-are-white-values-1518333 https://www.newsweek.com/smithsonian-race-guidelines-rationa... My suspicion is that the woke know very well that their ideology is very brittle. Maybe it wasn't in the beginning, but by now it has been embellished by so many absurdities that even Titania McGrath cannot keep up. And the only way how to avoid the explosion and crash of the brittle ideology is never to confront it with logic and critical thinking. Which you only can do by associating rationality with the worst possible label, racism. Some people will do anything not to be labeled racist. Of course, if the woke can really get away with that, China will eat Western Civ alive. Without the scientific method, West is just a random bunch of mostly Indoeuropean-speaking territories. We were once the boring backwater of the world. We can return to that state again.
- candiodari 6y ago> Of course, if the woke can really get away with that, ... What do all ideologies say to the god of reality ? "Not today"
- nxc18 6y agoI wish the leftists doing things like this would take the time to think about the consequences. It isn’t helping their cause to make clowns of themselves. That is painful as someone who genuinely wants to see reform and many leftist ideas succeed.
- andyxor 6y agohttps://archive.is/UKcal https://archive.is/UKcal
- fallingfrog 6y agoFox News culture wars bullshit, in which the work of a small group is cherry picked and taken out of context and calculated to feed the outrage machine. Gotta get those clicks. You’re being manipulated.
- noofen 6y ago> You're being manipulated. https://equitablemath.org/ https://equitablemath.org/ Stop lying.
- fallingfrog 6y agoI do not lie. You are misrepresenting the text you just posted a link to. I think the authors are wrong in several ways, but this is a tempest in a teapot and designed to generate outrage. And it’s working too!
- opwieurposiu 6y agoSee also, Illinois Rep wants to cancel history: https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/chicago-area-leaders-call-for-illinois-to-eliminate-history-classes/2315752/ https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/chicago-area-leaders-c...
- Simulacra 6y agoThis is not going to be a popular statement but I'm deeply worried Generation Z is going to turn out to be Generation Zero; no proper education, no work ethic, fortitude, or convictions. Our education system is a mess and it's creating a generation that I fear will be largely absent from progress.
- randyrand 6y agothis has been a mainstream opinion for the past 4000 years or so. Its well documented in Thucydides Greek classical texts.
- WalterBright 6y agoCalifornia isn't the only place getting rid of gifted programs: https://www.thestranger.com/slog/2020/01/24/42658513/seattle-school-board-takes-steps-to-dismantle-gifted-program https://www.thestranger.com/slog/2020/01/24/42658513/seattle...
- bobochan 6y ago"Many highly selective colleges expect students to take calculus in high school." Which is exactly why this is not about "gifted" students (whatever that means), but about a lot of students that are interested in math and science and would like to be prepared for first year courses that expect them to at least have exposure to calculus. To put it in context, California was the state that was looking at stripping the requirement for passing Algebra II as a condition of graduating from community college a few years ago: https://www.latimes.com/local/education/la-me-intermediate-algebra-qa-20170630-htmlstory.html https://www.latimes.com/local/education/la-me-intermediate-a...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 6y agoI once hired an outfit to install a patio in the yard. They gave me a bid based on per-square-foot cost, which I accepted. They leveled it and staked out the elliptical shape. I'm a very poor judge of size, but something made me suspicious and I brought out the measuring tape. Did a little calculation based on the formula for the area of an ellipse. It was 30% smaller than the contract bid. There was a couple pallets of bricks for it in the street. I measured a brick and did a little multiplication, and discovered that the quantity of bricks matched the measured size, not the the contract bid. I called them up, and they denied it, then said they'd made a math mistake. Baloney. They were trying to cheat me. I hypothesized that they'd discovered that few people noticed when they oversized the square footage in the contract, and they kept going further and further with that, and expected to get away with being a full 30% off. Knowing a bit of high school geometry paid a big dividend that time for me.
- TimTheTinker 6y agoLink to the manual proposed for use: https://equitablemath.org/ https://equitablemath.org/. The PDF downloads have a lot of content... it would take a while to digest all that is in them. I'm all for social equality and getting rid of racism (i.e. the horrible practice of discriminating against people, even implicitly, on the basis of race), but calling out "objectivity" and "either-or thinking" as characteristics of white supremacy seems way over-the-top. Either we teach people from the Western tradition of pedagogy, or we don't. But deconstructing the basic tenets of western philosophy and calling them "white supremacist" is absurd. It also distracts from what actually hurts people of color and other marginalized groups, thus perpetuating the problem.
- 1cvmask 6y agoThe Equitablemath organization wants to dumb down public school students in California (disproportionately black and brown) and is funded by super rich whites (Bill and Melinda Gates). Bill Gates went to the elite private Lakeside high school with a great Math curriculum. He clearly does not see the people of color as worthy of that by this very funding. This was actual state policy towards blacks and people of color in Apartheid South Africa. The denial of a traditional mathematics education to everyone should be a crime.
- username90 6y agoWhy don't you split California so Los Angeles and San Francisco are no longer in the same state? Their cultures seems so different I don't see why not.
- threatofrain 6y agoWhat is the top systemic practice which sustains white supremacy in Californian math pedagogy? What is the leading argument?
- keithalewis 6y ago1 + 1 = 3 for large values of 1.
- WalterBright 6y agoGutting mathematics teaching in public schools can only bring out more inequality, not less. It will widen the gap between public and private schools.
- andyxor 6y agowhy is this flagged?
- fallingfrog 6y agoBecause it’s ideological flamebait designed to trigger the amygdala rather than inform and educate. As soon as I read the editorial I felt upset, confused, angry- and that of course is how I was intended to feel. A hit piece like this is perfectly designed to trigger you. What’s really dismaying is that so many seemingly rational people here on hacker essentially fell for it.. You let them take your rational mind and replace it with a vehicle for propagating the priorities of the author of the article. And it’s so, so easy for that to happen. It’s happened to me. And once you’ve fallen for something like this, it’s very, very hard to admit that you’ve been had.
- zigzags 6y agoI'm not going to defend the social justice components of the proposed curriculum (https://equitablemath.org/ https://equitablemath.org/), which I don't think are appropriate to focus on in a math class. However, I think some of the comments here are a little off-base and miss out on some of the better ideas proposed. For instance, the curriculum doesn't actually seem to say that students shouldn't show work or that there isn't a "right answer" but rather that teachers should allow (even encourage) students to explore multiple approaches to arrive at a solution instead of enforcing the idea that there is only one right way to do things. Note that you can still have a "right answer" which can be obtained in multiple ways. This is coming from the second manual: https://equitablemath.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2020/11/2_STRIDE2.pdf https://equitablemath.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2020/11... As someone who researches and teaches computational mathematics at a university, I think this approach is really what we should be encouraging. After all, this is the way in which mathematics is actually practiced. Of course, this also requires teachers to be able to understand and teach multiple approaches to the same problem which is another can of worms, and it is probably the biggest source of frustration for students when this isn't the case.
- valbaca 6y agoI understand the outrage, but please hear me out. Some background on myself: I'm a Latino with a B.S. in Computer Science with a minor in Math. I'm very good at math. Less so now but I was absolutely in the "gifted" category with math. I took a math minor because I wanted more classes I'd enjoy and knew it would help my GPA because I've aced every math class I've taken. I'm literally an A-plus math student. So is math racist? Well it's never called me any names, so I'd say no. Are they trying to say that "correct" is now "wrong"? No. However, what we're talking about here is math INSTRUCTION and the culture in which we're teaching math. Ultimately what they're attempting to address is that the way math is being taught is not reaching many students of color and white students as well! We've been taught that rote memorization and the correct answer is the end-all-be-all, but consider the student that just memorizes but doesn't understand, or another that gets the correct answer because they made two mistakes that cancel out or the student that understands, but made an off-by-one error. The first student will never see how this applies "to the real world" and gives up on math as interesting. Or will grow up, like many, and never know how to apply math to situations. I know friends who have "pi-r-squared" but can't find the diameter of a beach ball given a string and a measuring tape. Or they bemoan "why didn't they teach us how to do taxes???" but never understand that they were taught percentages! The second student is worse off. They just got there by luck and that luck eventually runs out. Then math will seem arcane and mysterious. They'll say it changes and doesn't make sense. They won't learn the beauty in logical steps. Finally, the last student, the one closest to understanding and being good at math and could even be great at math, is given a point off; just "wrong". The way math is taught and the way we even do math isn't set in stone and can evolve. We adopted Arabic numerals because they were superior to Roman numerals. We adapted the concepts of zero, and infinity, and the concept of infinitesimal, and computer-assisted proofs when at one point they were rejected by the "math community" (or whatever that looked like at the time). There's nothing to say that the precise way we teach math is the absolute best that there can be. I'm assuming that like many others here, "showing your work" was the worst part of math. But reason why because teachers only cared if you approached math in the way that they understood and had taught it. I never memorized my "times tables" because I hated rote-based math. Instead, I had internalized the concept of associativity (at the time I didn't know the name for it). So while I didn't (and still don't) have 7x8 memorized, I know 7x7 + 7 is the same, and that applies for any larger number. So while others couldn't multiply 21x21 in their head, because it was outside the range of their "times tables", I could. I would get into fights with my math teachers constantly in elementary because my mind made leaps their teaching didn't or wouldn't account for. I matured and learned in middle and high school to backtrack and show the "baby steps" for my teacher's sake and ultimately my own sake. Our current way of teaching doesn't meet everyone's needs and doesn't encourage a deep understanding of math, its benefits, its application, and its development. Our country bemoans how there's a STEM-shortage, but we won't analyze that there might be different and better ways (or worse ways!) to communicate math because we think it would disrupt the idea that there's only one way to do math. Now is this (https://equitablemath.org/faq/ https://equitablemath.org/faq/) the right way to do that? I don't know. Probably not, but I'm also not an educator. What I can see is that the US is doing an abysmal job of teaching math and an even worse job of teaching to everyone equitably and we have to change that somehow.
- kxyvr 6y agoFor anyone looking at this, please note that this is an editorial written by an educational activist and not a news article, nor a statement of fact. I will contend that what was written is deceptive and is more or less a gish gallop, which makes it difficult, time consuming, and tedious to refute point by point. The actual documents can be found here: https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/ma/cf/index.asp https://www.cde.ca.gov/ci/ma/cf/index.asp As for some specific items that have come up and and elsewhere on the internet, no, California is not advocating for eliminating calculus from the curriculum. This is discussed in Chapter 8. This is an open discussion of whether or not students should be pushed to get into calculus by grade 12. Part of the thinking is that it's possible, but the students end up with some very shallow understanding of the material. Meaning, they can compute a u-substitution, but don't really understand what a derivative or integral means. They may be better off getting a better foundation and then taking calculus in college rather than just pushing for calculus. Other options are discussed on line 340. No, California is not advocating eliminating gifted programs. This is discussed in Chapter 1 starting around line 415 and intersects with comments about calculus. It does offer a discussion about whether or not tracking kids into gifted programs does them more harm than good in some situations because priority can often be given towards keeping up with advanced topics rather than deeper understanding. Other organizations such as the MAA also have opinions on this. And, look, I'm not contending that anyone here needs to agree or disagree with the proposals from California. However, I will strongly contend that there's a lot of anger against something that really does not exist in the form that is editorialized. The editorial freely picks and chooses quotes out of context and freely mixes them some with truths and some with lies, which makes it truly exhausting to dissect.
- Balgair 6y agohttps://equitablemath.org/?emci=826b0dfc-e5f2-ea11-99c3-00155d039e74&emdi=635de139-eaf2-ea11-99c3-00155d039e74&ceid=308754 https://equitablemath.org/?emci=826b0dfc-e5f2-ea11-99c3-0015... Download Stride 1, go to page 66. That section, though a bit loopy, is not about basic math. It's about data science, stats, and word problems. Areas well open to interpretation. Other portions are like this too. I'd disagree with the headlines, but the foundational ideas and workbooks are okay to my eyes (I'm not a teacher, so I may be missing big stuff). On having many answers, consider an abacus instead of paper. That's the stuff they are talking about. They state this: "Of course, most math problems have correct answers, but sometimes there can be more than one way to interpret a problem, especially word problems, leading to more than one possible right answer. And teaching math isn't just about solving specific problems. It's about helping students understand the deeper mathematical concepts so that they can apply them throughout their lives. Students can arrive at the right answer without grasping the bigger concept; or they can have an “aha” moment when they see why they got an answer wrong. Sometimes a wrong answer sheds more light than a right answer." The authors have ~5 hours of videos explaining these workbooks. I've not watched them though. The parent article is 'clickbait'/fake-news (from what I can see before the pay-wall). The material and what the authors are saying seems, to my quick glance, to be as boring as the math classes I remember (though strangely worded).