Not really. And this is why analogies can be bad. A better analogy would be that this is like someone's business getting robbed, and being punished for paying

Not really. And this is why analogies can be bad. A better analogy would be that this is like someone's business getting robbed, and being punished for paying the robber who flew overseas to ship it back to you. But still, this is different, more complex, and more nuanced.