3 ms·
Wouldn’t people with unreported income not be at the top of the income distribution, by definition?
by fortran77 6y ago
Wouldn’t people with unreported income not be at the top of the income distribution, by definition?
- okamiueru 6y agoNo? Unless you mean to say that the only way to make money is to not pay taxes, and not only that, but if anyone makes more money than someone else, they do so by paying less taxes.
- fortran77 6y agoI'm not sure how your statement follows what I said. I was indicating that there may be a lot of people that appear "poor" to the IRS with neither a lot of income nor a lot of losses/deductions to offset income that may in fact be earning a lot of money. And efforts to enforce tax collection of the "rich" will not identify these people. This article specifically talks about _unreported income_ among the "top of the income distribution". I'm saying that if they're known to the IRS as being at the "top of the income distribution" what may be lurking below the top that goes uninvestigated. > After correcting for this bias, we find that unreported income as a fraction of true income rises from 7% in the bottom 50% to more than 20% in the top 1%, of which 6 percentage points correspond to undetected sophisticated evasion. Accounting for tax evasion increases the top 1% fiscal income share significantly.
- okamiueru 6y agoI was being a little bit facetious in my attempt to point out the problems with the "by definition". There are two factors: the amount earned, and the percentage of that taxed. Tax evasion is paying less than what one "should" (everyone probably knows what I mean, but this can be nitpicked, so I'm adding quotes), for that amount earned. You are right in that the amount of unpaid taxes is more easily larger the more you earn, but by no means is a definition here that follows. Your point, as you explain it here is still a valid one though, but I didn't read your prior post as to mean the same. Since tax evasion can be both hiding income, as well as finding loop holes. Maybe they are more the same than I had thought. Hm. Maybe I learned something. As I see it, for rich enough people, tax evasion is akin to a tax on moral conscience. They pay as much as they think they should, or so it seems.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoIt's hard to hide a lot of money. You can dodge taxes fairly completely when you're small (think cash only employment and side gig) and there's not much to tax but they have plenty of incentive to track you down and get your money if you get big and it's hard to hide that much money moving around. Government isn't gonna let that much money slip through its fingers. So the rich report their income, mostly, or at least enough of it to be rich on paper. They just minimize their liability as much as they can.
- breakyerself 6y agoExcept people with a lot of money can afford a team of lawyers and accountants to grapple with the IRS. Middle income people can't afford to fight back. The path of least resistance is to ignore the big fish and just catch as many small fish as you can.
- vmception 6y ago> Grapple I think this completely mischaracterizes the relationship that wealthy participants have with the IRS. Factor in these two things: 1) The relationship with the IRS for the wealthy is not adversarial like 100% of the interactions with the IRS are with poorer people. Very many interactions with the IRS are pre-emptive as well as collaborative. The poorer experience is completely retroactive enforcement with the tax authority seemingly already having made a conclusion about what you owe at the worst time for you to come up with that money. Very big difference in experiences. 2) Lawyers and accountants know the law better than the IRS. Yes, “fighting back” can be an accurate term, but its more accurate to say “respond” at all. On the wealthier side, it is rare that an interpretation devolves into an adversarial relationship. The IRS is motivated by having a clear lineage of funds and rationale, as opposed to actually optimizing revenues via taxes.
- aaron-santos 6y ago>The relationship with the IRS for the wealthy is not adversarial like 100% of the interactions with the IRS are with poorer people. The working class gets audit mail, while the capitalist class get to talk face to face. It is the privilege of talking it over. If you can take just a moment to view the IRS as a customer support line, the rich get to talk with a real human.
- toast0 6y agoNot really. There's a question of if we're talking about the reported income distribution or the actual income distribution, of course. If it's reported income distribution, you could have a lot of reported income as well as some amount of unreported income. If it's total income distribution; having a lot of unreported income would put you at the top, but of course, it's hard to know about it, unless the income is discovered.