5 ms·
The difference is that with PoW you constantly have to do "stuff" (ie. buying equipment, running datacenters) or get left behind. PoS on the other hand you can
by gruez 6y ago
The difference is that with PoW you constantly have to do "stuff" (ie. buying equipment, running datacenters) or get left behind. PoS on the other hand you can just sit on your ass and wait for the $$$ to roll in.
- yokem55 6y agoExcept, using the same kind of pooling that POW depends on, you can still get in at just about any price level. .01 Eth can be staked just as easily as 10,000 eth. And running a validator with 32 isn't nothing - you still have to keep a machine on and online 24/7 with an uncapped connection or pay someone to host that machine.
- nerdponx 6y agoOr you can pay someone a flat amount to do the "stuff" and experience your own unlimited percentage-based gains, like in pretty much any other market where "capital" is a thing.
- sergioisidoro 6y agoGood point. But I still don't understand how it changes the premise presented by the comment, of "The one who has the money controls the network".
- pinkybanana 6y agoThere are lots of participants in the global economy who has money. The idea is that you have enough different people with competing incentives. PoW provides incentive model which separates different actors (pools, exchanges etc) and also at the same time doesn't seem to lead to monopolies.
- meowkit 6y agoCan you explain what “sitting on your ass” means? I thought you had to maintain a validator?
- sendbitcoins 6y agoExchanges like CoinBase will stake for you. You as an individual don't have to do anything.
- G3rn0ti 6y agoAn earn interest, right? So I could lend Coinbase some of my ether for staking and they pay me interest in return. So PoS could give us an interesting investment possibility.
- sendbitcoins 6y agoWell, its not called interest, its called 'staking rewards'. You can also earn interest lending out your ETH, but that's a different process and entails counterparty risk.
- tux3 6y agoYes and no. Keeping up with the day to day details is something you delegate at some point. PoW is also "just" an investment, with extra steps to set things up.
- narush 6y agoThis is not the case. In Ethereum's PoS model, you put value at risk when you sign up to be a validator. You have to lock funds up to play a part in consensus. This means that if you start acting maliciously, or even just not fulfilling your responsibilities (e.g. you let your computer go offline), then you are punished for it (depending on the severity of your offense, obviously). Aka, you can't just wait for the money to roll in. You have to run a node, you have to verify blocks, and you have to make sure you're acting in the best interest of the network + keeping things running smoothly.
- secondcoming 6y agoWho gets these funds? This is beginning to sound suspicious.
- thebean11 6y agoThe other actors in the network running validators. Specifically you are punished for: - Being offline (the penalty is small, and roughly equal to the rewards earned by being online - Running the same validator twice (huge penalty, be careful!)
- secondcoming 6y agoAre the funds paid in fiat or ETH?
- bidirectional 6y agoETH of course, this is an automated part of how the system works, not some behind-the-scenes deal based on reputation or whatever.
- f38zf5vdt 6y agoThis is something I don't understand. You lock the funds on a chain and you lose them on the chain. But what happens if two groups decide to split the chain, and both chains lock the opposing chains funds? It seems like there's no way to prevent social forks in the longer term, just a lot of hand-waving about that if the current social contract stays in place, some minority malicious group will be punished for secession. It would seem that if some participants on the network can't abide by their national laws while running some contracts, the outcome would be inevitable. And then you would just get multiple chains running under multiple governments. This seems like a reinvention of the international banking system?
- Polygator 6y agoYeah, but obviously the "stuff" has led to a Red Queen problem, with the outcome being incredible waste of electricity and computing resources (compared to PoS or having a less competitive eth mining industry)
- shawnz 6y agoIn PoS, you are still permanently burning the time value of the money you have staked. That's unrecoverable just like the electricity spent in PoW is unrecoverable.
- serverholic 6y agoI find comments like yours hilarious. The idea that the ethereum foundation has spent years and years designing a PoS system, writing papers, doing tests, building proofs of correctness aaaaaand derp they just didn't think of people sitting on their asses.
- arrow7000 6y agoMaybe answer the question instead of scoffing at how ridiculous it is?
- serverholic 6y agoNo, I refuse to put in effort to correct the level of confident ignorance the OP displayed.
- AlexandrB 6y agoIt's not that hilarious when you realize that this is the same kind of thinking some cryto-boosters apply to hundreds of years of financial regulation and history.
- everfree 6y agoThis isn't really true. You also have to buy equipment and run specialized software to participate in PoS. It requires keeping a node connected to the internet with high uptime, and maintaining its software and hardware. Plus, due to slashing, you are uniquely responsible for mistakes your validator makes. So, staking comes with both responsibilities and consequences for breaching them, just like any legal contract. The fact that you can rent a turnkey cloud solution to do all this work for you and split the profits isn't really relevant to the argument IMO (I consider staking with Coinbase "renting cloud computing" in a specialized way).