4 ms·
The better way to address this would be reducing copyright lengths to 20 years or something reasonable.
by lotsofpulp 6y ago
The better way to address this would be reducing copyright lengths to 20 years or something reasonable.
- mikeryan 6y agoNot from the studios perspective. They want the exclusivity.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoYes, so the proper way to help consumers is to remove the exclusivity and deal with the problem directly. Preventing mergers does not do anything, except add a middleman.
- bilbo0s 6y agoThis. Why is everyone ignoring these obvious solutions? I feel like there are these enormous movements out there to advance byzantine solutions to problems we could readily address with simple new rules. What's worse, these movements champion things like break ups, which will never work for the vast majority of these firms. Many are not monopolies, and do not operate as trusts. (Though FB, Google, and Amazon come closest.) Meeting legal definitions matter to Supremes. No matter how silly the legal definitions may seem to us as laymen. Two simple new rules. One, make the using of the private data of any user for commercial purposes explicitly illegal with draconian fines assessed per individual violation, not per user. Two, redo copyright in the manner you suggest. No more renewing for what becomes something akin to a copyright perpetuity. These two rule changes would neuter the power of a lot of these companies.
- thiago_fm 6y agoAgree. Those copyright laws were put into place a long time ago and made sense in the context of the past. Nowadays, they should just create a new one that fits the new distribution ways.
- e3bc54b2 6y agoThat means losing out exclusivity on endless remakes, reboots and sequels. Since that's the majority of Hollywood money, I sincerely doubt it will change.
- vmception 6y agoMany legislative opportunities just require shining a light on it. Disney lobbied for copyright lengths and other protections because nobody else cared. And didn't ask for more over recent years because people cared. You can do the same thing. There are many neglected and unused regulations because markets never formed around them. Congress or a regulatory body thought they were doing something useful but werent.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoTrademarks would prevent derivative works after expiration.
- WorldMaker 6y agoRemakes/reboots/sequels keep the brand fresh (add new copyrighted elements) and keep trademarkable items relevant and trademarked, so even if copyright terms were shrunk again, it wouldn't mean fewer remakes/reboots/sequels, nor would it reduce "exclusivity" of them, given the trademark moat. It would probably mean more remakes/reboots/sequels at standard intervals to "refresh" copyright/trademarks and keep the moat full. (Even Disney has publicly recognized to their shareholders their mistake in backing the previous copyright extension act and have no further reason to back more extensions because they've proven the trademark and trade dress moat is plenty sufficient. Seriously, try to make a commercial Steamboat Willy derivative all you want without using Mickey characters or concepts from later shorts/movies/pop culture. Try to do it without violating Disney's long held trademark on Mickey's general head shape. Or to use a different huge empire's with a giant moat of properties, some of the earliest Batman stories just finally entered the public domain, but there's almost no way to commercially create a new Batman story without accidentally using later still copyrighted ideas/characters [early Batman used a gun, feels sometimes unrecognizable to modern expectations; most of his favorite rogues didn't show up for decades later] and without violating extensive trademarks on Bat emblems and the cowl shape, etc.)